Received: from mp.cs.niu.edu (root@mp.cs.niu.edu [131.156.1.2]) by library.wustl.edu (8.8.5/8.8.5) with ESMTP id RAA17803; Sat, 30 Jan 1999 17:01:44 -0600 (CST) Received: by mp.cs.niu.edu (8.9.1/8.9.2) id PAA17872 for nepal-dist; Sat, 30 Jan 1999 15:23:48 -0600 (CST) Received: by mp.cs.niu.edu (8.9.1/8.9.2) id PAA17868 for nepal-list; Sat, 30 Jan 1999 15:23:46 -0600 (CST) Date: Sat, 30 Jan 1999 15:23:46 -0600 (CST) Message-Id: <199901302123.PAA17868@mp.cs.niu.edu> Reply-to: The Nepal Digest <NEPAL@cs.niu.edu> From: The Editor <NEPAL-REQUEST@cs.niu.edu> Sender: "Rajpal J.P. Singh" <A10RJS1@cs.niu.edu> Subject: The Nepal Digest - Jan 27, 1999 (10 Magh 2055 BkSm) To: <NEPAL@cs.niu.edu> Content-Type: text Status: O X-Status: X-Keywords: X-UID: 297
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
% N N EEEEEE PPPPPP AA L %
% NN N E P P A A L %
% N N N EEEE P P A A L %
% N N N E PPPPPP AAAAAA L %
% N NN E P A A L %
% N N EEEEEE P A A LLLLLL %
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
The Nepal Digest Wednesday Jan 27, 1999: Magh 10 2055BS: Year8 Volume82 Issue2
HAPPY NEW YEAR 1999 !!!
Today's Topics (partial list):
******************************************************************************
* TND (The Nepal Digest) Editorial Board *
* -------------------------------------- *
* *
* The Nepal Digest: General Information tnd@nepal.org *
* Chief Editor: Rajpal JP Singh a10rjs1@mp.cs.niu.edu *
* (Open Position) *
* Editorial Columnist: Pramod K. Mishra pkm@acpub.duke.edu *
* Sports Correspondent: Avinaya Rana avinayar@touro.edu *
* Co-ordinating Director - Australia Chapter (TND Foundation) *
* Dr. Krishna B. Hamal HamalK@dist.gov.au *
* Co-ordinating Director - Canada Chapter (TND Foundation) *
* Anil Shrestha SHRESTHA@CROP.UOGUELPH.CA *
* SCN Correspondent: Open Position *
* *
* TND Archives: http://library.wustl.edu/~listmgr/tnd/ *
* TND Foundation: http://www.nepal.org tnd@nepal.org *
* WebSlingers: Open Position tnd@nepal.org *
* *
* +++++ Food For Thought +++++ *
* *
* "Heros are the ones who give a bit of themselves to the community" *
* "Democracy perishes among the silent crowd" -Sirdar_Khalifa *
* *
******************************************************************************
******************************************************************
From: "Barbara Pijan Lama" <b_pijan@email.msn.com>
To: <NEPAL@cs.niu.edu>
Subject: Looking for Nepalese in Alaska
Date: Wed, 23 Dec 1998 22:08:41 -0800
Namaste Nepal Digest,
Would you please include the following message in your next edition.
Thank you, Sherpa Friendship Association.
From: John N. Glor <john_glor@yahoo.com>
Date: Wednesday, December 23, 1998 11:11 AM
Subject: Nepalese in Alaska?
Sherpa Friendship Association,
Greetings!
My wife and I were wondering if your organization was aware of any
Nepalese people living in Alaska. We haven't had any success in
locating a Nepalese community in the state.
Feel free to forward this message or distribute our email:
john_glor@yahoo.com
Thanks and Happy Holidays!
John & Bich Maya
***********************************************************************
Date: Thu, 24 Dec 1998 10:03:17 -0600
From: Padam Sharma <psharma@Soils.Umn.EDU>
Subject: SEASONS GREETINGS AND HAPPY NEW YEAR 1999!!!
To: The Nepal Digest <nepal@cs.niu.edu>
On behalf of the Board of Directors of Empower Nepal Foundation, I wish
you and your loved ones a very happy and healthy holiday season and a
prosperous New Year.
Padam Prasad Sharma, President
Empower Nepal Foundation
2000 Como Avenue
St. Paul, MN 55108
Phone: (612) 644-3733
Email: psharma@soils.umn.edu
********************************************************************
Date: Sun, 27 Dec 1998 10:15:56 -0500 (EST)
Forwarded by: Ashutosh Tiwari <tiwari@fas.harvard.edu>
To: nepal@cs.niu.edu
Subject: Book Review (fwd)
Source: The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, vol 3, no 17, 27 Dec 1998
Educational Challenges in South Asia
___________________________________
Human Development in South Asia 1998
by Mahbub Ul Haq & Khadija Haq
Oxford University Press, Pakistan, 1998
___________________________________
By Pramod Bhatta
As we approach the next millennium, it is a stark truth that South Asia
will emerge as the poorest region in the world, not only economically but
also socially as demonstrated by the Human Development Indices for the
region. Home to one-fourth of humanity, South Asia is already the most
illiterate, the poorest, the most malnourished and the least gender
sensitive - indeed the most deprived - region in the world. The first Human
Development in South Asia report conveyed this shocking message in 1997.
This second report focuses on the critical role of education in acclerating
human development in the region. There are more than 50 million children in
South Asia who have never seen the inside of a school. About 40 percent of
those enrolled drop out annully. About 395 million adults remain
illiterate, of which two-third are women. All South Asian nations had once
stated that they would extend basic education to all by the year 2000. This
is definitely beyond their reach.
But neglecting education now means adding more illiterates to the already
massive pool of uneducated South Asians. As Mistral poignantly said, "Many
of the things we need can wait; the child cannot .... Her name is today."
Yet, despite these highly disturbing facts, Universal Primary Education
(UPE) in the next five years is not a utopian vision for South Asia but an
achievable reality. Policy makers, especially politicians, must act now to
end the region's shameful neglect of basic education. This is the central
message of the Human Development in South Asia 1998.
Divided into ten chapters that include numerous boxes, tables, statistical
diagrams and technical notes, this book begins with the message: "the
challenge for South Asia today is to travel the vast distance between its
performance and its promise....by a massive investment in human development
whose critical components include basic education for all and building
relevant technical skills." Additional evidence is collected from the
experiences of the East Asian Tigers, Latin American countries and even
some African nations where massive investments in education have acclerated
social and economic progress.
According to the report, South Asia's educational challenge include low
access, low achievement and low completion rates. Six major tasks need to
be done to meet this challenge: i) enrolling all children in primary
education; ii) improving the quality and relevance of education; iii)
providing more and qualified teachers; iv) removing all forms of gender
disparities; v) building relevant technical skills; and vi) mobilizing
financial resources more properly.
This means creating school facilities for an additional 65 million
children, training an addition 2.05 million teachers (three-fourth of them
females), promoting non-formal, cost-effective high quality education,
decentralizing education programs, and producing a socially relevant
curriculum. This also requires persuading at least 20% of secondary
schoolers to opt for vocational and technical education and producing
skilled labour force as demanded by the market. To achieve this all, a
firm political commitment not only in words but also in deeds is
necessary, backed up by allocating about 1% of the combined GNP of the
region for education. Thus the report not only details the meagre state of
education in South Asia but also provides a strategy to ensure UPE within
the next five years, provided that there is a strong committment from all
appropriate sectors.
Whether any policy execution will follow from such a situational analysis
is still questionable. However some promising signs have been noted. For
example, in Bangladesh and certain states of India and Pakistan, the
governments have collaborated with NGOs to improve the performance of
educational institutions. Statistically speaking, the results from such
experiences are quite encouraging. But in Nepal - where the role of NGOs
has not been properly defined and other civil society institutions remain
ill-developed - the same may not be easily achievable.
The report says that "income poverty is no barrier to the spread of basic
education" but it also says that "Poverty has an enormous bearing on girls'
chances of schooling." These are two apparently contradictory statements. A
sound political committment as envisaged by the report may not be possible
in the near future while the political leaders relish on the massive
support of student bodies. However, this bluntly frank report should come
as a rude shock to all those development practitioners of the region who
still believe that economic development can be achieved independently of
human development. Such 'experts' and Nepal's politicians should read this
report carefully and think about meeting the challenges described therein.
(P Bhatta is an MA student in sociology at TU)
********************************************************
Date: Mon, 21 Dec 1998 00:09:19 EST
From: CVehlow@aol.com
To: tnd@nepal.org
Subject: greetings
In April 13-17, 1999, the Akron Child Guidance Center will sponsor the XI
world congress of the International family therapy association. It is a cross
cultural experience, focused on the family. I am interested in finding a
scholarship for someone there to attend the first time in the USA congress.
Can you help?
charles vehlow
*********************************************************
Date: Tue, 29 Dec 1998 00:54:02 -0600
From: Padam Sharma <psharma@Soils.Umn.EDU>
To: Nepal Digest <nepal@cs.niu.edu>
Subject: Empower Nepal Foundation: Introduction/Update and Appeal for Support
EMPOWER NEPAL FOUNDATION
2000 Como Avenue, St. Paul, MN 55108, USA
Email: empowernepal@mailexcite.com
Website:http://empowernepal.hypermart.net/
Dear Friend(s):
Increasing pressure from a rapidly expanding population in Nepal is
impacting socio-environmental relationships, which in turn, is degrading
the environment and quality of life at an alarming rate. While
reinstitution of democratic system of governance since the early 90's is
yet to show political maturity and direction, it has provided
opportunities
for empowerment of local communities to solve local problems. The
purpose
of this letter is to introduce you to Empower Nepal Foundation, which
aspires to network with caring individuals like you to bring resources
to
these communities.
The mission of Empower Nepal Foundation is to pool together ideas and
resources of individuals and institutions from around the world and
disseminate the resources to empower the people of Nepal with
information
and support needed to help them help themselves improve and sustain the
environment and quality of life.
The guiding philosophy of ENF is based on the premise that given
information, education, and vocational opportunities, Nepali individuals
can excel to their best, earn a decent living, and pursue happiness
through
investments in further education of their children and welfare of their
family, friends, and community. The personal, academic, and
professional
successes achieved by you and other Nepali individuals in world class
academic and non-academic institutions prove this axiom. Similarly, we
strongly believe that, only by investing on education, the country of
Nepal
can tap the unlimited potential of human and natural resources and scale
the Sagarmatha of human dignity and environmental quality.
Incorporated in the State of Minnesota, USA, ENF is a public supported
non-profit organization dedicated to bring volunteered and philanthropic
resources to Nepal. In the past two years of its existence, ENF has
accomplished the following:
* Incorporated the organization, instituted the Board of Directors;
passed bylaws and directives for fiscal responsibilities and
administrative frugality.
* Received IRS approval as a public supported nonprofit organization
under US Internal Rev. Code 501(c)(3).
* The Directors and other supporters contributed seed money and
volunteered hundreds of hours of time for organization development,
fund raising, and information dissemination.
* To date, ENF has raised about $ 6500 through individual
contributions
and fund raising activities.
Initiated the following two projects in Nepal:
* Scholarship for secondary school children in rural Nepal: With $50
per
student per year, ENF has started supporting five children from
socially and economically under-privileged families to attend
middle
school classes at Nangi (a Magar village) in Myagdi District of
mid-western Nepal. A local committee of volunteer teachers and
community leaders administers the scholarship program.
* Sponsorship of women’s groups for socio-economic development. With
$350 per group, ENF is sponsoring two women’s adult education
programs
at Thulagaon and Dandagaun (Gurung and Tamang villages) in Rasuwa
District. Educate the Children (ETC), a nonprofit organization
from
Ithaca, New York and Kathmandu, administers the program. Besides
literacy, the women participate in income generation, health,
sanitation, environmental restoration, and community development
activities and learn team building and leadership skills.
These projects are very small in dollar amounts and number of recipients
the programs serve at this time. However, these programs exemplify
important beginnings as ENF starts to demonstrate how sponsor’s
contributions are being used to invest into the future of Nepal. To
those
of us who are actively involved in the upbringing of ENF organization,
these achievements are spiritually rewarding as our love for Nepal is
being
translated into deeds.
The plan is to add more students and adults into the education program
each
year. As we collect more resources, we intend to develop and fund other
projects on education, environmental restoration, and socio-economic
development. At this time, we are looking at a two track approach
towards
funding these projects. One, we annually solicit contributions from
sponsors like you, and two, we are setting up an endowment fund that
would
generate income for future projects. Currently, any specifically
dedicated
contribution, and 20% of all general ENF contributions are set aside to
develop the endowment fund for the scholarship project.
ENF is established to encourage and facilitate you to look for ways to
contribute to the future of Nepal. As ENF has demonstrated in a small
way,
by networking together, we can show other and better examples of good
deeds
and get the satisfaction of working for Nepal no matter where we live in
this world. ENF is collecting money, not to hand out to individuals or
give it to a self-serving NGO in Kathmandu, but to provide matching
support
to commitment by individual sponsors and local communities to mobilize
volunteered and philanthropic resources for the project. ENF intends to
use the pooled resources to challenge and match the individual and
group’s
efforts to develop neighborhoods and villages. By working closely with
the
sponsor and the recipient community, ENF strives to maximize the
effectiveness of our hard-earned dollars and minimize the misuse of
project
funds.
We need your monetary contribution and support to carryout ENF’s mission
activities in Nepal. You decide on the amount you can afford and the
cause
you want to support. For example, with $15, you can double the annual
budget for teaching materials of a public primary school in rural Nepal.
With $50, you can sponsor a child to stay in school for a year and help
the
school buy the teaching materials. With $100, you can buy materials to
paint the school or add books in the library. With $1000 you can be a
patron of ENF and help a 4th grader graduate through high school or
renovate the school building that the child goes to. You can setup a
scholarship program, build a school, or supplement teachers' salaries in
the name of your loved ones whose memory you want to cherish. You can
support women’s socio-economic development programs, build a drinking
water
project, sponsor immunization and sanitation programs, or help develop a
cooperative business. You can help plant trees, conserve soil, build
community parks, and clean neighborhoods. Together, we all help Nepal
one
individual, one family, one neighborhood, and one community at a time.
Needs abound in Nepal, and list of things we can do is limitless. In
Mother Teressa's words, "While we cannot do all the great things that we
want to do at once, we can surely do small things with great love", one
quality project at a time.
We are asking for your support in this noble endeavor of building a
resource base which community leaders in Nepal can tap into. If you are
already funding your own individual project in Nepal, or considering
funding one in the future, or building a Nepal support network of
individuals in your city or state, let us explore how we can network
together and learn from each other. You can Email us individually or
give
us a call to find out more about ENF and share your thoughts on how we
should help Nepal. Please visit our developing Web site at
http://empowernepal.hypermart.net/ and let us know how we are doing.
Please send your check to Empower Nepal Foundation, 2000 Como Avenue,
St.
Paul, MN 55108. All donations to ENF are tax deductible.
Thank you for considering ENF as your institution to invest into the
future
of Nepal.
Sincerely,
Empower Nepal Foundation Board of Directors
Padam Sharma, Environmental Soil Scientist. Phone: (651) 644-3733.
Email:
psharma@soils.umn.edu.
Bhairav Khakural, Environmental Soil Scientist and Computer Consultant.
Phone: (651) 649-0952. Email: khakural@soils.umn.edu.
Sambedan Bhattarai, Electrical Engineer. Phone: (612) 887-2812. Email:
Sam_bhattarai@notes.seagate.com.
Bhaskar Tripathy, Computer Consultant. Phone: (651) 683-9173. Email:
nt_netware@topservice.com.
Nirmal Bhattarai, Adult Educator. Phone: (651) 642-9145. Email:
nirmal@migizi.org.
Bijaya Karki, Research Physicist. Phone: (651) 645-5261. Email:
karki@cems.umn.edu.
Sagun Karmacharya, Computer Consultant: (612) 89-8974. Email:
sagun@IPCS.net.
EMPOWER NEPAL FOUNDATION
Bringing People and Resources Together for Nepal
******************************************************
Date: Jan 1, 1999
From: Anil Sakya
Subject: Lumbini: A Nepalese Buddhist journal is available for free
2nd issue of LUMBINI, a Nepalese Buddhist journal in the UK is available
for free
What is LUMBINI?
LUMBINI is the journal of the Lumbini Nepalese Buddha Dharma Society
(UK) and published biannually (May & November). It is distributed free
of charge for one who is interested in Nepalese Buddhism and Buddhism in
general.
What is LNBDS?
For centuries Buddhism remained the religion of the East. At present,
more and more Westerners come to learn about Buddhism and practice its
teachings for the spiritual and physical well-being and happiness. As a
result of this interest many monasteries and Buddhist organisations have
been established in the West. Most have Asian connections but some are
unique to the West e.g. Friends of Western Buddhist Order. Nepalese,
residing in the United Kingdom, wishing to practice Buddha Dharma for
their spiritual development, turned to them as there were no such
Nepalese organisations. Therefore, a group of Nepalese met in February
1997 and founded Lumbini Nepalese Buddha Dharma Society (UK) to fill
this gap. The society is non political, non racial, non profit making
voluntary organisation and open to all, both Nepalese and non-Nepalese,
whatever their faith.
Objectives of LNBDS
1. To make Buddhism known to the wider public and to help them
understand the benefits of its profound teachings.
2. To have a forum for the meeting of Nepalese residents in the UK and
others with an interest in Buddha Dharma as a spiritual practice for
discussion, exchange of ideas, constructive dialogue and to build
Nepalese Buddhist community in the UK.
3. To establish links with similar organisations in the UK, Nepal and
other countries.
4. To organise voluntary work to help reduce human suffering in Nepal
and
5. To promote and publish religious and cultural heritage of Nepal
LUMBINI: A Nepalese Buddhist journal
The inaugural issue was published on May 1998 as a souvenir for Vaisakh
Purnima celebration in the UK. The event was organised by the LNBDS. It
was unprecedented Vaisakh Purnima Day celebration in the UK as it was
done in the Nepalese Buddhist traditional way.
The 2nd issue of LUMBINI is out now and distributed free of charge on
request.
Highlights in LUMBINI (2nd issue):
1. Lumbini Today by Arjun Pradhan and Amrit Sthapit
2. Buddhist Ethics by Prof. Peter Harvey
3. Highland Buddhism of Nepal by Anil Sakya
4. Who's who in Nepalese Buddhism by Dhammasakiyo
5. Buddhism in Picture: Story of Kisagotami (drawings)
6. Crossword (Buddhism+Nepal)
7. Can one be a Buddhist without believing in rebirth? by Bhikkhu
Sugandha
8. In Nepali language: Nepali Buddha Dharma ra Baudha Samskriti by
Bhikshu Sudarshan
Anyone who is keen to receive the journal please send a written request
to:
The Lumbini Nepalese Buddha Dharma Society (UK)
11 Mulburry Drive, Slough
Berks SL3 7JU
United Kingdom
or e-mail request to
anil.sakya@brunel.ac.uk
*************************************************************
Date: Tue, 29 Dec 1998 11:09:23 -0500 (EST)
Forwarded by: Ashutosh Tiwari <tiwari@fas.harvard.edu>
To: nepal@cs.niu.edu
Subject: Book review
Source: The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, vol 3, no 17, 27 Dec 1998
Educational Challenges in South Asia
___________________________________
BOOK: Human Development in South Asia 1998
by Mahbub Ul Haq & Khadija Haq
Oxford University Press, Pakistan, 1998
___________________________________
By Pramod Bhatta
As we approach the next millennium, it is a stark truth that South Asia
will emerge as the poorest region in the world, not only economically but
also socially as demonstrated by the Human Development Indices for the
region. Home to one-fourth of humanity, South Asia is already the most
illiterate, the poorest, the most malnourished and the least gender
sensitive - indeed the most deprived - region in the world. The first Human
Development in South Asia report conveyed this shocking message in 1997.
This second report focuses on the critical role of education in acclerating
human development in the region. There are more than 50 million children in
South Asia who have never seen the inside of a school. About 40 percent of
those enrolled drop out annully. About 395 million adults remain
illiterate, of which two-third are women. All South Asian nations had once
stated that they would extend basic education to all by the year 2000. This
is definitely beyond their reach.
But neglecting education now means adding more illiterates to the already
massive pool of uneducated South Asians. As Mistral poignantly said, "Many
of the things we need can wait; the child cannot .... Her name is today."
Yet, despite these highly disturbing facts, Universal Primary Education
(UPE) in the next five years is not a utopian vision for South Asia but an
achievable reality. Policy makers, especially politicians, must act now to
end the region's shameful neglect of basic education. This is the central
message of the Human Development in South Asia 1998.
Divided into ten chapters that include numerous boxes, tables, statistical
diagrams and technical notes, this book begins with the message: "the
challenge for South Asia today is to travel the vast distance between its
performance and its promise....by a massive investment in human development
whose critical components include basic education for all and building
relevant technical skills." Additional evidence is collected from the
experiences of the East Asian Tigers, Latin American countries and even
some African nations where massive investments in education have acclerated
social and economic progress.
According to the report, South Asia's educational challenge include low
access, low achievement and low completion rates. Six major tasks need to
be done to meet this challenge: i) enrolling all children in primary
education; ii) improving the quality and relevance of education; iii)
providing more and qualified teachers; iv) removing all forms of gender
disparities; v) building relevant technical skills; and vi) mobilizing
financial resources more properly.
This means creating school facilities for an additional 65 million
children, training an addition 2.05 million teachers (three-fourth of them
females), promoting non-formal, cost-effective high quality education,
decentralizing education programs, and producing a socially relevant
curriculum. This also requires persuading at least 20% of secondary
schoolers to opt for vocational and technical education and producing
skilled labour force as demanded by the market. To achieve this all, a
firm political commitment not only in words but also in deeds is
necessary, backed up by allocating about 1% of the combined GNP of the
region for education. Thus the report not only details the meagre state of
education in South Asia but also provides a strategy to ensure UPE within
the next five years, provided that there is a strong committment from all
appropriate sectors.
Whether any policy execution will follow from such a situational analysis
is still questionable. However some promising signs have been noted. For
example, in Bangladesh and certain states of India and Pakistan, the
governments have collaborated with NGOs to improve the performance of
educational institutions. Statistically speaking, the results from such
experiences are quite encouraging. But in Nepal - where the role of NGOs
has not been properly defined and other civil society institutions remain
ill-developed - the same may not be easily achievable.
The report says that "income poverty is no barrier to the spread of basic
education" but it also says that "Poverty has an enormous bearing on girls'
chances of schooling." These are two apparently contradictory statements. A
sound political committment as envisaged by the report may not be possible
in the near future while the political leaders relish on the massive
support of student bodies. However, this bluntly frank report should come
as a rude shock to all those development practitioners of the region who
still believe that economic development can be achieved independently of
human development. Such 'experts' and Nepal's politicians should read this
report carefully and think about meeting the challenges described therein.
(P Bhatta is an MA student in sociology at TU)
Source: The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, vol 3, no 17, 27 Dec 1998
Book, or Glossy Vanity
by C K Lal
Professionals crave peer recognition. Acquiring acceptance by building up a
series of successes in one's chosen field of endeavor is a long, arduous
and time consuming process. It's relatively easier to write a jargon-filled
book to establish your credentials. The fear of being found out is not
there because every one indulges in this kind of 'ritualistic scholarship'
all the time. Lack of originality can easily be compensated for by copious
quotes and thick bibliographies to prove that adequate 're-search' has been
done. Thus, one witnesses a rush of professionals responding to the urge of
getting into 'blue covers.'
To attempt to review Urban & Environmental Planning in Nepal: Analysis,
Policies and Proposals by Dr. Ambika Prasad Adhikary (IUCN Nepal, 1998) is
in itself giving it more attention than it deserves. If it were not for its
excellent production, I would have hesitated to do it. Color printing on a
thick glossy art-board cover is arresting. Overall layout of the book
matches international standards.
Print quality is beyond reproach, though I
couldn't find printers' name anywhere in the book and am unable to say
whether it was produced here or abroad. Dilip K. Munankarmi, the designer
of the book,
deserves all the credit for making me buy this book. Quite naturally, it's
him that I blame for having prompted me into wasting two hundred rupees of
my hard-earned money in buying a book that I could have easily done
without.
On the credit page, author asserts that views expressed in the book are
those of him and should not be construed as the official views of IUCN
Nepal or IUCN. All right, but that disclaimer does not bar me from blaming
either IUCN Nepal for publishing the book or the Swiss Agency for
Development and Cooperation for supporting this enterprise. Aid-money
should not be squandered away in financing ego trips of ambitious
professionals. Oh, I am straying. I am supposed to discuss the content of
the book.
The 'contents' page is innovative. It uses 'all caps' for chapter headings
and 'all small' for sub-chapter titles. However, once inside, the chapter
titles have also been demoted to small letters. Does Munankarmi have a
message hidden somewhere there? Does he want readers to concentrate more on
the accompanying quotes, sketches and
photographs? Tables of figure, graphs and illustrations are interestingly
displayed. I am having difficulty focusing upon the contents. Well, I guess
I must, otherwise the Coordinator of this review page will throw this piece
in the nearest waste paper basket and, in total ten-hours of my effort
involved in trying to read this book, along with it.
In the first section, author says, "In this book is expected to contribute
towards better understanding of urban and environmental problems in Nepal
and to help in the development and implementation of practical solutions to
the problems of planning and environment." The author is Ivy League quality
- Harvard - with a stint each at MIT and easy going University of Hawaii.
Obviously a comparatively illiterate person like me can't dare question his
assumptions (The role of a book in implementation of practical solutions,
understanding of urban and environment, not urban environment, issues in
one slim volume), ambitions (planning and environment, development and
implementation, urban and environment) or his English ( In this book is
expected ... ). I am one of those who hold the view that even if a Ph.D.
commits a mistake, it must be deliberate. A pundit is always right.
Let me face failure, it's extremely difficult to talk about the contents of
the book. For a "better understanding of urban and environmental problems
of Nepal," issues should have been analyzed in context, in content and with
contemplation (The 3Cs of the jargon) for a proper diagnosis. In stead, we
are given loads of generalization like "Baneshwarisation" and some more of
pontificating on "Standardization" as prescriptions of all illnesses
afflicting our urban centers, and even those are too Kathmandu-centric to
be of any use any where else in Nepal. I give up the pretensions of a
review altogether. Why discuss a book that is not meant to be read by any
one? One is expected to buy
this kind of books to decorate one's book-selves.
The small-town characteristics of a thriving rumor culture still hold sway
in an otherwise cosmopolitan Kathmandu. One such rumor that floated for
quite a while in the circles of intelligentsia concerned IUCN. It appears
that Dr. Harka Gurung and Dr. Ambika Adhikary were two of the main
contenders for the post of Country Representative of that organization.
The contrasts in the personalities of these two imminent individuals are
spectacular. Dr. Gurung is an ethnic non-caste Hindu, an earthy geographer,
a former politician, a prolific writer, shows up in Nepali topi and talks
about his travels in Nepal rather than Naples. In short, he is a man one
would like to have tea with. On the other hand, Dr.
Adhikary is a high-caste bahun, an aesthetic architect, a former teacher,
impeccably turned out, articulating his words carefully and dropping Ivy
League names meaningfully. He is just the kind of person you would like to
tee off. Elite institutions like IUCN prefer the later types and publish
books that can be inscribed upon by their high profile authors on the golf
courses in between holes so that holes can be made
in deep pockets while raising funds for a cause. This book can serve that
implicit purpose exceedingly well.
Finally, I regret having taken up the responsibility of reviewing this
book. I am not a very good critic because I like to be liked. To be
praised, one must praise and I must make one last ditch effort in that
direction. If you want to buy some items of interior decoration, pick up
this book along with the crystal ash trays, bone-china flower-vases and
jade figurines. This book will look good on your carved coffee table and
will show your class. It has been thoughtfully produced in soft-cover so
that you can get it hard-bound in leather by hand before having it
monogrammed in gold. However, like all precious possessions, this book
should be handled with care and never opened if possible. At least, not
unless absolutely necessary to show the biography of the author on the back
cover to adulatory guests.
See the power of this book? It has made me fill sentence after sentence
with 'Is' and 'mes'. Vanity rubs off as easily as the gloss on expensive
covers. That's the highest accolade one can give to a book of collection of
rehashed essays published to impress rather than inspire.
(C K Lal is waiting to defend his Master's thesis on Urban Planning at the
Institute of Engineering, TU)
Source: The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, vol 3, no 17, 27 Dec 1998
Nepali Christians at Large
___________________________
BOOK: Nepali Around the World: Emphasizing Nepali Christians of the
Himalayas
by Cindy L. Perry
Kathmandu: Ekta Books, 1997, Rs. 600
___________________________________
by Carrie Williams
It's a pity that Cindy L. Perry's Nepali Around the World is not as
approachable as its lovely cover and simple title promise, because its
subject is one that many will benefit from exploring. The work was
originally presented as Perry's doctoral thesis at the University of
Edinburgh under the less misleading title, "The History of the Expansion of
Protestant Christianity among the Nepali Diaspora." Although the book is
written from a Christian perspective and primarily intended for a Christian
audience, the history Perry
describes and the issues her work raises are of much broader relevance.
As its original title suggests, Nepali Around the World explores the
history of emigration from Nepal and conversion to Christianity among
various Nepali diaspora groups. Perry begins with a chapter entitled "Who
is a Nepali?," in which she gives a taxonomy of the cultural and ethnic
groups who populate Nepal and discusses some reasons for emigration. In the
following four sections, she gives a hefty region-by-region description of
Nepali emigration and conversion. Perry divides this analysis into four
sections:
The Eastern Himalayas; North East India and Burma; North, North
West, and Urban India; and The Gurkhas and Nepali Overseas. For each
section, she gives a brief history of emigration followed by more detailed
descriptions of specific communities and the history of the spread of
Christianity among them. Analysis of this information is almost entirely
confined to the concluding chapter, in which she discusses the
"missiological issues" raised and suggests effective methods for "reaching"
more of the Nepali diaspora with the Christian message.
The sheer volume of information collected here -- and the work that was
obviously involved in this book's construction -- is impressive in itself.
Perry describes some of the challenges involved: "dearth of comprehensive
documentation or published accounts available....[t]he common practice of
lumping Nepali together with Indians, and the generalised use of the term
'Gurkhas' (not differentiating between soldiers and the general
populace)." It quickly becomes clear that the process of writing this was,
in Perry's words, like putting together the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle, but
first having to find the pieces.
Because of its groundbreaking nature, this book will certainly be welcomed
by members of Nepali Christian communities who, Perry points out, are often
not in touch with Nepali Christian groups in other locations. Likewise,
Christians of all nationalities will welcome Nepali Around the World as an
addition to the record of Christian history.
For others, this book might serve to open up new avenues of thinking about
conversion of Nepali people to Christianity. Perry's detailed accounts of
the spread of Christianity among groups of Nepalis outside of Nepal show
the variety of reasons and contexts for conversion, giving depth and
texture to a phenomenon that's often looked at one-dimensionally,
particularly by those who oppose it. Similarly, Perry's descriptions of the
ways in which Christianity has been brought into Nepal by Nepalis who
converted outside the country may surprise those who attribute the growth
of Christianity in Nepal solely to Western money and coercion.
A disturbing weakness is Perry's failure to state her point of view or to
examine the effects of her biases on her portrayal of historical events.
Although she never states it explicitly, Perry's evangelical Christian
perspective is evident, particularly in the final chapter, where nearly all
of her analysis is pointed toward discerning which methods are most
"effective" in "reaching" Nepali diaspora communities with the Christian
message.
While the effect of Perry's religious point of view on her analysis is
fairly transparent, its influence on the body of the work -- the accounts
of Nepali immigration and conversion in various areas -- is much less
clear. As I read I wondered what this same work would look like had it been
researched and written by a non-Christian. What sorts of information were
emphasized or overlooked as a result of Perry's religious orientation? As a
Christian, Perry may have goals quite different from a non-Christian
academic's, and it wouldn't make sense to ask her to set those aside. But
in a scholarly work such as this, it seems reasonable to expect an
explanation of her perspective and some attempt at
analyzing its effects on the types of information she's obtained.
Even without that sort of self-reflection, this volume can be of interest
and help to students -- both Christian and non-Christian -- of history and
religion, or to anyone interested in the dynamics of emigration and
conversion. The region-by-region descriptions, though thick, can be
informative if read with a critical eye; the bibliography is superb; and
the appendices include intriguing primary source material.
All in all, this is an impressive and important compilation of previously
uncollected information, but it's a shame the finished product doesn't seem
to be meant to be read. In fact, while slogging through the densely
detailed historical accounts peppered with somewhat embarrassing copy
editing oversights, I wondered occasionally how many other people had
managed -- or ever would manage -- to read the entire volume. Nepali Around
the World is a Ph.D. thesis, the main goal of which is not to enrapture or
inform the public but to compile and analyze information and to demonstrate
the author's prowess as an academic. Perhaps it would have been better to
keep this version for the historical archives and publish a slightly more
reader-friendly digest rather than the detail-heavy, analysis-light tome
lurking between the friendly looking covers of this volume. However, in the
absence of such a publication, Nepali Around the World is worth a look.
(Williams is a Fulbright grantee studying expatriate missionaries in
Kathmandu)
Source: The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, vol 3, no 17, 27 Dec 1998
Documenting Pastoral Landscapes
________________________
BOOK: Fields of Grass: Portraits of the Pastoral Landscape and
Nomads of the Tibetan Plateau and Himalayas
by Daniel J Miller
ICIMOD, Kathmandu, 1998, Rs. 2200
___________________________________
by Pratyoush Onta
Fields of Grass will come as a surprise to those who associate the Tibetan
Plateau and the Himalayas to snow-covered desolate lands only. Its
immaculate photos - over 220 of them - and the accompanying texts, however,
will be a feast to those interested in the nomads and grasslands of Nepali
and Tibetan highlands. Nomads or nomadic pastoralists are people who
"specialize in animal husbandry that requires periodic movement of their
herds."
The American photographer-author, Daniel J Miller, first came to Nepal in
1974 as a Peace Corps Volunteer. He spent four years in northern Nepal,
working and living with yak herders. "Yak herding," Miller found out "was a
fascinating way of life and the pastures the yaks grazed in a remarkable
landscape." He sometimes accompanied yak caravans to the Tibet-Nepal border
but could not actually visit Tibet as it was closed to foreigners. After
returning to the US, Miller studied ecology of rangelands - areas that are
unsuitable for agricultural cultivation but serve as source of forage for
animals. He returned to this region in 1983 and worked in the field of
range-livestock development and wildlife conservation in Nepal, Bhutan,
China, Mongolia and Pakistan.
For two years starting in 1995 Miller worked as a rangeland specialist for
ICIMOD. He first visited Tibetan grazing lands in 1988 and by 1997, he had
made 15 trips to pastoral areas in Tibet and passed through similar areas
of Nepal and Bhutan on numerous occasions. In his introduction to the book,
Miller provides a brief history of nomadic pastoralism in the Tibetan
Plateau and Himalayas and compares it with pastoral regions of Eurasia and
Africa. He also highlights the many characteristics shared by the nomads of
the region.
The photos included in the book span the years from 1975 to 1997.
Documenting in photographs "the nomadic way of life and the transformations
nomad society was going through," Miller has created a visible archive "of
the landscape and the uses it had been subjected to by people and their
livestock." The photos and the texts are presented under titles such as
pastoral landscape, pastoral production, livestock, nomads, changes and
future challenges.
Miller's photos show the internal variety in the rangelands found in China,
Nepal and Bhutan. They also record the various pastoral production
practices and strategies that have been historically adopted by nomads in
these countries who usually own a mix of different species of animals. This
is a strategy that maximises their use of rangeland resources and minimises
the risk of losses that can result from diseases. Livestock photographs
show yaks, sheep, goats, and horses. Photographs of nomads show women and
men from Langtang, Solu and Dolpo in Nepal; from Yunnan, Qinghai, Sichuan,
and Tibet in China; and from Sakten in Bhutan.
Under "Changes", Miller documents transformations in the use and conditions
of rangelands, and in the lives of pastoralists. The long-term prospects of
nomadic pastoralism in the region, according to Miller, are good but will
require suitably designed research and management programs. A reading list
and a selection of photos from the book that are useful for repeat
photography, a valuable tool to analyse changes, are included at the end.
All in all, this is a fascinating book.
(P. Onta hosts Dabali, a discussion program on Radio Sagarmatha FM 102.4,
two times a week)
Source: The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, vol 3, no 17, 27 Dec 1998
A Mediocre Compendium
________________
BOOK: Contemporary Nepal
Edited by Pashupati SJB Rana and Dwarika Nath Dhungel
Delhi: Vikas Publishing House, 1998, IRs. 395
________________________________________
by Anil Baral
Nepal is endowed with bountiful nature. Snow-clad mountains to the north,
fertile plains to the south, and beautiful valleys interspersedwith green
lush hills in the middle set a perfect landscape one could ever dream of.
Moreover, her multi-ethnic setting, varied languages, colorful rituals,
richness of traditional arts and crafts together constitute the icing on
the cake for foreigners willing to venture into Nepal. Hold on! Nepal is
not only a paradise of touristic imagination.
There are also disquieting
and dismal faces of Nepal that belittle her charm. Grinding poverty,
glaring gender discrimination, poor access to basic social services such as
education, nutrition and health services, mounting ecological imbalance
are there for everyone to see. Contemporary Nepal is an invitation to
look at the partly composite picture of Nepal through the eyes of Nepali
scholars from diverse backgrounds, and at best to judge their analyses.
Partly composite in a sense that it fails to cover some important facets
of Nepal, notably contemporary arts and literature, tourism, health and
education. However, it must be acknowledged that to undertake the task of
representing the composite picture of contemporary Nepal in one book is
itself an arduous assignment.
For common readers accustomed to reading novels in which plots captivate him/her
from the beginning to end, textbook-like Contemporary Nepal will be a
difficult read.
It contains thirteen articles from eleven writers who deal with themes such
as nationalism, culture, economy, foreign policy, environment and gender.
An introduction by the editors summarizes the contents of each article.
Beginning with "The Land and the People" by Sant Bahadur Gurung and ending
with Arju Rana Deuba's "Empowering Nepalese Women: What are the Chances?",
the book is an amalgamation of a few provocative and many insipid articles.
Gurung's essay and Sushil Bhattarai's article on "Ecology and Environment"
are congregations of facts not bolstered with good analyses. "The Evolution
of Nepalese Nationalism" by editor Rana, on the other hand, is analytical
in its treatment of the theme. He describes four different types of
developments in the history of nationalism, namely territorial nationalism
(British or French pattern), linguistic nationalism, anti-colonial
nationalism and created nationalism and relates them to the evolution of
nationalism during different phases of Nepali history.
"We are standing in
the phase of created nationalism which is partly cemented by anti-Indian
sentiment" argues Rana. In addition, the emergence of regional, communal
and linguistic issues in the course of electoral politics has established
sectoral nationalism which is threatening the nation's integration. Rana is
rightly justified in arguing that "representation and distribution are the
major mechanisms required to resolve the conflict of this phase of
'created nationalism' in Nepal." Binayak Bhadra's essay on energy,
environment and human development is a down-to-earth presentation in which
he advocates small hydro power plants for rural electrification. This, he
argues, will reduce the dependence on fuel wood, generate small enterprises
and uplift the rural economy.
The other essays - "The Culture of Nepal" (Jagadish SJB Rana), "The
Nepalese Administrative System" (Dhungel) and "Prospects and Retrospect of
NGOs in Nepal" (Diwakar Chand), Nepalese Foreign Policy (T.N. Jaiswal) -
begin with a historical background and describe the developments in the
specified subjects through the contemporary period. It is hard to
understand why the editors chose to include both "Gender and Development:
Nepalese Perspective" by Padma Mathema and Deuba's "Empowering Nepalese
Women." The former alone adequately depicts the gender issues in Nepal. Had
the latter been replaced by an article on the arts, literature or tourism,
it would have expanded the coverage of the book.
Few titillating potentials and recommendations aside, most articles are
implicitly pessimistic regarding Nepal's development. For instance, editor
Rana whines "Nepal lacks a charismatic leader with a broad vision and
strong political commitment to steer the country out of the prevailing
chaos."
The articles can be classified broadly as good and mediocre. Rana's
earlier mentioned piece and Gunanidhi Sharma's "The Economy of Nepal: A
Macroeconomic Overview" are good articles; Gurung's, Bhattarai's and
Deuba's essays are mediocre ones. The rest fall somewhere in between. The
book comes with a dull layout and occasional spelling errors. On the whole,
it is unlikely to generate much inspring debate about contemporary Nepal.
(Baral is doing research on environmental issues)
*********************************************************
Date: Wed, 30 Dec 1998 14:37:27 -0500 (EST)
From: BIPULENDU NARAYAN SINGH <singhb@wabash.edu>
Subject: madhuri dixit episode - matter of great shame
To: NEPAL@cs.niu.edu
The Madhuri Dixit episode to me is a matter of great shame
to Nepal. Here we have a actress saying some what rightly that
Nepal was once a part of india and a whole group of students
shouting slogans against her.
Has our sense of self fallen down so much that we have to prove it
everytime by embarking on yet another anti-India rhetoric? I am a
nationalist and I believe in nationalism but I refuse to be a part of a
nationalism that is built on hatred of others and even more on
hatred of a country with which we share so many historical and
cultural ties.
Afterall what is Nepal and what is India? Aren't there as many (if not
more) nepali speaking people in India (remember Darjeeling,
nagaland) as there are in Nepal. Aren't there as many (if not more)
Maithali speaking people, bhojpuri speaking people, as many
Sherpa's, and Limbu's in india as in Nepal. Did not Buddha who
was born in what is Nepal not gain enlightement in what is India
now? Did not Sita who was born in Janakpur marry Ram in
Ayodhya? Aren't our own kings decendents of Rajasthani Rajputs?
Can you please tell me what was Nepal then and what was India?
wasn't everything just made up of small kingdoms which together
were known as Bharatbarsa ( or India to foreigners). What was
Nepal before Prithivi Narayan shah conquered a group of
kingdoms just a few centuries ago?.And if this not enough there is
some more.
Did not BP koirala fight for the Indian independence (there is a
road named after him in calcutta) as did he for Nepal's
independence. Do not many of our citizens fight for the Indian
army? Haven't many of our political leaders spent the greater part
of their lives in India? Haven't Manisha koirala and Udit Narayan
embraced by India in the indian movie industry. Does not India
allow Don't many of our people (especially in Terai) have strong
links with people in India.
Can you just cut everything into two pieces. Say this is Nepal and
that is India. Aren't we being anti-Nepal in being anti-india . Isn't our
hatred based on an imperfect knowledge of our self? Will we not
destroy ourself if we destroy india?
******************************************************************
Date: Sun, 03 Jan 1999 16:10:57 -0500
From: "Paramendra Bhagat"<paramendra_bhagat@smtpgtwy.berea.edu>
To: <nepal@cs.niu.edu>
Subject: Bhattarai : Burnt-Out and Out-Of-Touch
Koirala has made an attempt to project Krishna Prasad Bhattarai as the next
Prime Minister after admitting he orchestrated Bhattrai's defeat in the
parliamentary bi-election held while Koirala was Premier. This is too little,
too late. Bhattarai will go down in history as the Premier who lead the interim
government that gave the country its current constitution. He is no doubt a
towering figure in the country's five-decade-long struggle to institute
democracy in the land. But he is someone from the past. In the post-democracy
phase the country needs those who are more comfortable with the basics of a free
market economy and can engineer confidence in the political fabric of the
country so as to foster rapid economic growth. Bhattarai is not it. Koirala
never was. The likes of Deuba, who might be better suited, do not seem to be
able to muster the political strength to openly challenge Koirala within the
Nepali Congress and possibly even break away, Bamdev-style. I guess we are in
for yet another hung parliament where the largest party, whichever that might
be, itself will not have more than 60 seats. Nepal might be going Indian. In
that in India neither the BJP nor the Congress is anywhere near the majority
mark. In Nepal that is to be the fate of both the Congress and the UML. The
politicians in Kathamandu better brace themselves for a nascent culture of
coalition politics.
<http://www.info-nepal.com/p-review/1998/12/311298/dis.html>
The dissatisfied NC MPs include; Siddhiraj Jha, Bhakta Bahadur Balayar, Naresh
Bahadur Singh, Chakra Bahadur Shahi, Hasta Bahadur Malla, Moti Prasad Pahadi,
Ganesh Bahadur Khadka, Deepak Jung Shah, Chabi Prasad Devkota, Surendra Hamal,
Shivaraj Suvedi, Hari Prasad Chaudhari, Khum Bahadur Khadka, Dip Kumar Upadhaya,
Dhundiraj Shastri, Duryadhan Chaudhari, Devendra Raj Kandel, Amar Raj Kaini,
Indu Sharma Poudel, Krishna Bahadur Gurung, Shusil Man Sherchan, Palten Gurung,
Chirinjeevi Wagle, Ramchandra Adhikari, Chinkaji Shrestha, Kamala Pant, Arjun
Narsimgh KC, Gangadhar Lamshal, Surendra Chaudhari, Ramesh Rijal, Radhechandra
Yadav, Mohmad Aftab Alam, Uddav Dhakal, Harihar Yadav, Bajrakishore Singh, Ram
Hari Joshi, Mina Pandey, Mahendra Yadav, Saradsingh Bhandari, Dhurba Sharma,
Hemraj Dahal, Bhim Bahadur Tamang, Bimalendra Nidhi, Pradip Giri, Suresh Chandra
Das, Raj Dev Goit, Bijaya Gachhedar, Laxuman Mehta, Harinath Banstola,
Badrinarayan Basnet, Sher Bahadur Deuba, Bal Bahaudr Rai, Chandrakanta Dahal,
Bal Bahadur KC, Dipak Baskota and Mani Lama.
*************************************************************
Date: Tue, 05 Jan 1999 08:34:19 +0500
To: The Nepal Digest <nepal@cs.niu.edu>
From: "F.A.H. \('Hutch'\) Dalrymple" <hutch@htp.com.np>
Subject: 'Kathmandu Distopeia'
KATHMANDU DISTOPEIA!
Oh, poor Kathmandu!
Decaying,
Graying,
Crumbling,
Inefficiency
Laughing!
What is your legacy...?
A peaceful place?
Development?
Over population?
Violent revolution?
Earthquake?
A Tethys Sea again?
Oh, poor Kathmandu,
The tank of the serpent!
Why can't 'the serpent' get
Its tail straight again?
Why can't you rise to
Himalayan heights?
You were once great!
Uncoil your Kundali!
Ignore the 'giants'
To the north and south!
Overcome your penchant to accept
Things as they are!
Raise the bar!
Or, poor Kathmandu!
The rotting wooden temple!
Down,
And all around!
Garbage in the streets!
Choked air,
I dare you!
(Note: I challenge everyone living in Kathmandu to change the course of
history!)
Clean up your act!
Blame not the government
You are!
Wish not patriarchal help!
Do it yourselves!
We!
We are the 'wons!'
We!
You and me, citizens of
Kathmanwho?
Stop leaving at 5,
Shooting the jive!
Stay and work!
'Stop not until the goal is reached!'
Arise, awake!
Stop not until
The 'gold,' is reached!
Feed your teaming masses
Yearning to be free!
Arise, Awake!
Stop 'knot!'
Copyright, 1999
F.A.H. ('Hutch') Dalrymple
Kamaladi, Kathmandu, Ne-is-my-pal
225183
hutch@htp.com.np
*****************************************************************
Date: Fri, 08 Jan 1999 16:49:55 +0300
From: JFAX <jfx@diogen.asc.rssi.ru>
To: nepal@cs.niu.edu
Subject: Contact
Dear Sir,
Could you help me? Two years ago I had contact with Mr. Santa Subba
from "Kaila Himalaya Trek" Ltd.
Unfortunately his e-mail address seems out of work.
Please if you have any information about his contact address pass
it to me or advice Mr. Santa Subba to contact with me via e-mail:
vitaly@diogen.asc.rssi.ru.
Thank you in advance
Valentin Bozgukov.
*********************************************************************
From: "Paramendra Bhagat" <paramendra@hotmail.com>
To: nepal@cs.niu.edu
Subject: Links for future discussions on the National Economy
Date: Fri, 08 Jan 1999 16:26:17 PST
Nepal Human Development Report 1998
<http://www.nepali.net/undp/keydoc/nhdr98/contents.html>
Info-Nepal.com: Economy
<http://www.info-nepal.com/nhp/econ/econ.html>
The World Bank Group: Country Data on Nepal
<http://www.worldbank.org/data/countrydata/countrydata.html>
The World Bank in Nepal: Development Indicators
<http://www.worldbank.org.np/worldbank/indicator.html>
Structural Adjustment in Nepal
<http://www.worldbank.org/html/oed/pr122.htm>
Nepal: Environment and Development
<http://www.info-nepal.com/nhp/econ/env/unced.html>
Nepalnet: Economy
<http://www.PanAsia.org.sg/nepalnet/ecnoframe.htm>
People’s Review: Economic gloom and doom
<http://www.info-nepal.com/p-review/1999/01/070199/pol.html>
Nepal Human Development Report 1998
<http://www.nepali.net/undp/keydoc/nhdr98/contents.html>
Info-Nepal.com: Economy
<http://www.info-nepal.com/nhp/econ/econ.html>
The World Bank Group: Country Data on Nepal
<http://www.worldbank.org/data/countrydata/countrydata.html>
The World Bank in Nepal: Development Indicators
<http://www.worldbank.org.np/worldbank/indicator.html>
Structural Adjustment in Nepal
<http://www.worldbank.org/html/oed/pr122.htm>
Nepal: Environment and Development
<http://www.info-nepal.com/nhp/econ/env/unced.html>
Nepalnet: Economy
<http://www.PanAsia.org.sg/nepalnet/ecnoframe.htm>
People’s Review: Economic gloom and doom
<http://www.info-nepal.com/p-review/1999/01/070199/pol.html>
Economy of Nepal
<http://www.emulateme.com/economy/nepaeco.htm>
Theodora.com: Nepal’s Economy 1995
<http://www.theodora.com/wfb/nepal_economy.html>
Library of Congress: Nepal, Economy
<http://lcweb2.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/r?frd/cstdy:@field(DOCID+np0009)>
CIA World Fact Book: Nepal
<http://www.odci.gov/cia/publications/factbook/np.html>
Nepalpages.com: Doing business in Nepal
<http://www.nepalpages.com/pages/business.htm>
Center for Global Trade Development
<http://www.cgtd.com/global/asia/nepal.htm>
Webnepal.com: Economy
<http://www.webnepal.com/nepal/economy/economy.htm>
Ministry of Commerce: Export Promotion Board
<http://www.info-nepal.com/epb/>
Nepal Information Center: Business and Economy
<http://infosys.zdv.uni-mainz.de/~baadj000/economy.htm>
************************************************************
Date: Mon, 11 Jan 1999 02:55:47 -0500 (EST)
Forwarded by: Ashutosh Tiwari <tiwari@fas.harvard.edu>
To: nepal@cs.niu.edu
Subject: Micro-credit in Nepal
MICRO CREDIT IN NEPAL
Investing in the future-1
- By Rollie Del. Rosario
Senior Multimedia Coordinator, Asian Developmeent Bank
Nirmala Chaudhari begins her day at 2.30 a.m. By the flicker of a gas
lamp and earthen stove, she
prepares a light snack from the previous night's leftovers for her
younger children and brews tea for
the whole family. After cleaning the kitchen and attending to a few other
household chores, she
treks to the paddy field in the morning mist, carrying the farming
implements dictated by the season.
However, since last year, another task has been added to her morning
ritual before farm work:
feeding and milking the buffalo.
Although the buffalo has added at least another half hour to her 12-hour
workday, Nirmala does
not mind the added chore. Purchased through a loan of Nepali rupee (NRs)
15,000
(approximately US$250) from the Ghorahi branch of Nepal Bank Limited, one
of the banks
participating in the ADB-financed Microcredit Project for Women, the
buffalo is Nirmala's new
pride and joy. With milk selling at NRs 10 (US$ o.16) for a half liter,
she makes an average of
NRs 70 (about US$ 1.16 ) a day during the 14-odd months that the buffalo
produces milk.
Female calves are valuable since they can be used to breed and provide
more milk, while males
can be sold straight away or raised for plowing. Even the dung is used
for fuel as well as for
plastering exterior walls.
Nirmala has another reason to be happy. With an emergency personal loan
from Samaj Sewa
Bhaisi Palan Samudaya (Social Service Buffalo Raising Group) the
all-female savings and credit
group that guaranteed her loan for the buffalo she was able to repay her
debt of NRs
10,000(approximately US$166.66) to a village loan shark. Settling this
debt released her son from
kamaiya (bonded service for debt).
"Our son Chandra Prasad was a kamaiya. We had borrowed NRs 2,000 (about
US$33.33) from
them. We sent our third son to work for the money. He was 15 years old.
Later, my son did not
want to continue. He complained about being ill-treated. He complained
about being asked to
work on very difficult chores. He complained of not being fed well. We
asked him to continue but
he did not agree. The next year when he was to continue as kamaiya, they
came for him but he just
fled to India in anger.
"We had borrowed NRs2000 (about US$33.33) but later the loan amounted to
NRs 10,000
(approximately US$ 166.66). Then we borrowed from this group and paid
back the moneylender.
But my son is still in India."
Nirmala is a typical farmer housewife in Pakwauai, a small village in the
Dang valley, Western
Nepal. Born a Tharu (one of the largest Nepali ethnic communities) 34
years ago, she is the mother
of 12 children. Her family lives on public land and has very few
possessions. With no steady job
and no real property, she and her neighbors cultivate a small paddy field
and share its produce with
the landlord. Like most of her neighbors, she can only write her name and
copy a few letters of the
Nepali alphabet.
Dharma Kumari Gurung did not have much going for her a little more than a
year ago. Now a
single mother, she had given her small plot of land for her two sons'
dowries a few years earlier.
With very few and simple needs, she managed, at the age of 54, by doing
household chores for her
sisters-in-law with whom she lived. She also had a goat whose milk she
sold to make ends meet.
While collecting fodder for the goat, she fell from a tree and suffered
an open fracture in her right
leg which had already been fractured in a previous accident. The goat had
to be sold to pay for the
operation on her leg, and the medicines. Already frail to begin with, she
could no longer perform
heavy manual labor.
Physically handicapped, possessing meager savings, and emotionally
devasted, Dharma gathered
her wits and resolved to overcome her crisis. She moved to Pame, about an
hour's drive from
Pokhara, and joined one of the women's groups organized by the Women
Development Division
(WDD) of the Ministry of Local Development as part of the Microcredit
Project for Women.
Even then, it was not easy for Dharma. Because she was still recovering
from her leg injury, she
could not attend all the training workshops, which were part of the
program. Her group members
also harbored reservations about her disabilities.
"There was a time when others in the group had a very negative impression
about my being a
member of the group. There were doubts whether a physically impaired
person like me could
follow the rules of the program. I was badly ignored, but Sita Madam (one
of the motivators) came
to my rescue and talked to the rest of the group and then we all received
the loan.
"I have the courage to face the future I feel that I will have quite an
amount by the time I pass
away. I can take care of guests who visit me like my daughters and their
children. I can feed them
well. I cannot promise them wealth or property, but I can keep them happy
when they visit."
She has had no trouble paying back the first four of six instalments of
the loan. In fact, she is
seriously considering applying for a second loan once the first one is
repaid.
"I am the most regular in the group in terms of paying back. I am very
conscious about the fine that
results if I pay late.
"From this experience, I have developed self-confidence. Let me pay back
the remaining two
instalments. I will definitely apply for a second loan to produce bhujiya
(a Nepali delicacy of spiced
and salted flour noodles). This will net at least NRs 8001,000 (about
US$13.33-16.66) more a
month."
The difficulties encountered by Nirmala and Dharma are typical of the sad
state of rural women in
Nepal. In a country where about 40 percent of the people live in absolute
poverty, poor women
constitute the most marginalized group. About 94 percent of the poor live
in rural areas and 48
percent of these are women. More than 95 percent of economically active
women are engaged in
agricultural labor. Although they bear the brunt of farming as well as
household chores, they have
very little access to productive resources such as real property, cash
savings, and credit. Women
generally work harder and longer than men; plowing seems to be the only
agricultural activity
performed solely by men. With a female life expectancy of 52 years, Nepal
is one of only three
countries where women die earlier than men, who normally live to 55 or 56
years.
The Project has three major components. The group formation and Training
of Women
Beneficiaries component provides support to the WDD in the formation of
self-help women's
groups. Following a baseline survey of households in the 12 districts and
5 towns covered by the
Project, women development officers and volunteer motivators from
participating nongovernment
organizations (NGOs) started forming the groups. At the end of November
1997, a total of 2,524
groups, each consisting of 5-15 members, have been formed.
Each group has to open a savings account in one of the banks
participating in the Project. The
members decide among themselves the amount of the monthly contribution
per member, but the
average is NRs 215 (about US$0.41). Membership in a group entitles each
member to make a
loan of each member. However, only the groups whose monthly contributions
are up-to-date can
guarantee the individual loans of its members.
Aside from group formation, this component also provides for training the
groups in the rudiments
of savings, credit management, and bookkeeping, as well as various
income-generating and
livelihood activities, and the operation of micro-enterprises and small
business projects.
Because of the large number and extensive influence of NGOs in Nepal, the
Project has a separate
component for the institutional support of selected NGOs. The management,
accounting, technical,
and capital-generating capabilities of participating NGOs are being
strengthened with the aim of
enabling them to function as credit agents of the participating banks.
The partners NGOs are also
empowered to form grassroots savings and credit groups. For example,
Nirmala's buffalo-centered
self-help group was organized by the NGO Gramin Mahila Bikash Sanstha
(Association for Rural
Women's Development).
The most apparent Project component, the provision of credit to women,
makes funds available to
beneficiaries who have been organized and trained by WDD and partner NGOs
into stable and
functioning savings and credit self-help groups. The loans are channeled
through two participating
banks: the Nepal Bank Limited and the Rastriya Banijya Bank.
Medium-term loans up to NRs 30, 000(about US$500) are granted for
agriculture-based, income
generating activities. Owners of microenterprises such as handicrafts,
small restaurants, and
convenience stores can benefit from loans up to NRs 40,000
(aboutUS$666.66). Operators of
small businesses in urban areas can borrow NRs50,000-250,000(about
US$833-4,166). The
loans have a repayment period of up to seven years. They are guaranteed
by the security of the
group's savings. The loans for small businesses are backed by adequate
collateral.
As of mid-November 1997, 9,292 loans amounting to NRs114.7 million (more
than US$1.911
million) had been disbursed. The average repayment rate is 97 percent.
Beneficiaries can apply for
subsequent loans after full payment of their current account. Dr. Shambhu
Dhungana, consultant
team leader for the group formation and training component, explains, "We
would like to cultivate
the savings and credit habit. These women, the majority of whom used to
borrow money at very
onerous rates rates and under outrageous conditions, are now becoming
aware that other sources
of funds with comfortable rates and terms of settlement are available.
(To be Concluded)
*******************************************************************
Date: Mon, 11 Jan 1999 13:00:53 -0500 (EST)
Forwarded by: Ashutosh Tiwari <tiwari@fas.harvard.edu>
To: nepal@cs.niu.edu
The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, 10 Jan 1999
Vol 3, no. 18 coordinated by Dinesh Prasain.
Art and War
BOOK: Dancing in Cambodia, At Large in Burma
by Amitav Ghosh
Delhi: Ravi Dayal Publisher, 1998, IRs. 125
Reviewed by Manjushree Thapa
Amitav Ghosh is foremost a superb narrator. Whether writing novels like The
Circle of Reason, The Shadow Lines or Calcutta Chromosome, or literary
non-fiction like In an Antique Land, he is capable of moving forward
several stories simultaneously, shifting gracefully from character to
character, setting to setting, genre to genre, fiction to non-fiction, and
past to present to future. His latest
work, the travelogue Dancing in Cambodia, At Large in Burma is
marked by hi usual narrative deftness, offering the reader the chance to
read about many facets of Cambodia and Burma in the three short pieces
within.
Dancing in Cambodia's title piece is perhaps the most
skillfully crafted and most intensely felt, focusing ultimately on
what it means to be able to perform a traditional dance in the
war-torn Cambodia of the late 1980's. To place this question in
historical context, Ghosh begins his narrative with the story of
the 1906 arrival of King Sisowath in France, two years after the
Cambodian ruler came to power and handed France final control over his
nation.
The dancers accompanying King Sisowath stunned the French; the
painter Rodin was so infatuated with them that he
marveled in gratitude at the "royal honour" they had displayed by
dancing and posing for him. Through the story of King Sisowath's
travels to France, Ghosh also sets the stage for the history of
French colonialism which has torn Cambodia apart. The question of
what it means to dance in present-day Cambodia cannot be answered without
an examination of what national culture means.
Then the narrative cuts to 1993, to a meeting between Ghosh
and Pol Pot's sister-in-law Chea Samy, a onetime dancer in King
Sisowath's court who is currently working to revive traditional
dance after the devastation of the 1950's and 60's struggles for
independence and American saturation-bombing, the 1975 Khmer Rouge
revolution, and the 1979 Vietnamese invasion.
The meeting with Chea Samy takes place under telling circumstances.
Ghosh's interpreter for the meeting is a woman in her thirties whose
father, two brothers, and a sister were murdered by the Khmer Rouge.
Facing the brother and sister-in-law of Pol Pot is not without
considerable anguish for her; and yet she does it, and somehow nurtures
within her the complex emotions of reconciliation: "I wanted to attack him
when I first saw him.... But then I thought-it's not his fault. What has
he ever done to me?"
Indeed, most people in present day Cambodia seem haunted by the
proximity of those who belong to the "other side" and have, at some point,
wreaked grief upon themselves and their families. Accepting this grief, and
forgiving those who caused it, is part of what it takes to put on a
traditional dance. One of the spectators describes his experience of
gathering to watch the dance: 'We cried and laughed while we looked around
to see who were the others who had survived. We would shout with joy: "You
are still alive!" and then we would cry thinking of someone who had died.'
To dance in Cambodia is to defy the inhumanity of war.
This first piece in Dancing so eloquently raises questions
about the survival of humanity it can make the reader cry. Ghosh is
very mindful of history, but he never weighs down his narrative
with it; instead he adopts so light a touch that the delicacy of
the whole piece brings to life the very fragility of art.
The remaining two pieces of the book are more journalistic
in tone, and as such miss the shock and vibrancy of the first.
Still, they are complex portraits of contemporary Asia told by a
narrator who pursues difficult questions. "Stories in Stones" is a
short portrait of a man who survived Khmer Rouge labor camps and
decided, the day he saw Angkor Wat, to spend the rest of his life
there. In Ghosh's hands, his story becomes one of the many carved
into the stones of Angkor Wat.
"At Large in Burma" is a longer piece which wends its way through
Burma's postcolonial era to arrive at the present situation with Aung San
Suu Ki and the democracy movement. Ghosh's portrait of Suu Ki is
personable; his hesitation to ask her intensely personal questions is
refreshingly respectful, and (it is tempting to conclude) unique to an
Asian narrator. Suu Ki comes across vividly in her imprisonment and
defiance.
But it is through Ghosh's portrait of a Karenni rebel that he
reveals the complexity of Burma's current political instability, rife as it
is with ethnic tension. The rebel Ko Sonny is of Indian origin, and his
original name is Mahinder Singh. He is as much a vegetable farmer as a
warrior, as much a philosopher as yet another Asian adrift in the strange
displacing tides of our postmodern era. Ghosh's rendering of him gives a
glimpse of the complex Asian futures to come.
Dancing in Cambodia is travel writing at its finest, with a
narrator who takes the trouble to locate both his subject and his
own narrative position in history, and who has the skill to write
stories of war with the art they deserve.
(Manjushree Thapa is writing her first novel in Kathmandu)
____________________________________
BOOK: Nepal: A Himalayan Kingdom in Transition
by Pradyumna P. Karan & Hiroshi Ishii
The United Nations University, 1996, Rs 560
____________________________________
Reviewed By Abana Onta
Nepal: A Himalayan Kingdom in Transition analyses Nepal's efforts towards
development since the 1950s. It examines issues such as environment and
natural resources, land use, forests, agriculture, human resources,
cultural patterns, demography and urbanization, tourism, industrial
development and communication in the context of the mountainous terrain and
landlocked character of Nepal.
The authors assert that Nepal is presently experiencing a period of major
changes in its economy, society and environment. Since 1951 Nepal has
achieved much in its quest for economic and social development, but much is
left undone. Significant achievements in developing transport
infrastructure since 1951 have not been accompanied by faster economic
growth, reduction in the rate of population growth, increase in food
production, and employment generation needed to alleviate poverty.
Further, the authors emphasize the landlocked situation of Nepal and go on
to say that its consequences are difficult to quantify.
The authors also review the five year plans and policies from the years
between 1951 and 1995, and conclude that these plans have failed to fulfill
their purpose. Four decades of planning have not only increased the
development disparities between the eastern and the western regions of the
country but also between the mountains and the tarai regions as a result of
unequal investments in various geographic areas.
Further, the urban-centred development approach has not only widened the
spatial disparities between various areas, but also engendered a
non-sustainable and fragile economic base. The authors attribute several
factors to Nepal's failure in development planning. For example, a weak
and poorly developed organizational structure to formulate and implement
the plans contributed to disappointing results.
Top-down, donor-driven planning process devoid of concern for the local
people, selection of development projects on an ad hoc basis, heavy
dependence on external aid without regard to its socio-economic
justification, or long-range sustainability are few more examples of
ill-planning in Nepal's development. The authors conclude that the
planning process has taken place without genuine citizen participation and
the development decisions have beeen largely made by feudal bureaucrats
working under the influence of foreign aid regimes.
The authors do a good job in assessing the issues mentioned in the first
paragraph. Each issue has been discussed from various perspectives
including historical facts, planning and implementation aspects, emerging
problems, and pragmatic suggestions. The book points out gender and
urban-rural disparities, complex bureaucracy, lack of genuine community
participation, corruption, lack of skilled manpower, and political
uncertainty as hindrance to the development of Nepal.
The concluding chapter takes up three specific development challenges
facing Nepal: sustainable development and conservation, integration of
poverty alleviation programs with development strategies, and integration
of population issues into mainstream development.
However the remedies they recommend are so commonplace among the
prescriptions suggested by foreign scholars of Nepal that one can not find
anything fresh in them.
The authors seem to have failed to properly appreciate the information on
local issues they had at their disposal while proceeding through the book.
The authors, in the preceding chapters rightly point out the fact that
development failures in Nepal are bound up with complex social, political,
economic and cultural forces. After coming up with such analysis, it is a
pity that the authors revert to various "foreign development models" and
perhaps unjustifiably see great hopes in them for Nepal's redemption. Had
they ended the book with the same rigour with which they started it, the
conclusion would have been better. In conclusion, the book will be useful
to fresh college students in Nepal and neophyte Nepal hands abroad.
The Kathmandu Post Review of Books, 10 Jan 1999
Vol 3, no. 18 coordinated by Dinesh Prasain.
RECENT ARRIVALS: BOOKS
A Study in Nepali Economic History 1768-1846 by Mahesh C Regmi has been
reprinted (1999, Adroit Publishers, Rs 720). Originally published in 1971,
it was reprinted once in 1978 but has been out of print for over a decade.
One of the most fundamental texts of Nepali history, this book, in the
words of the author, "is essentially a description of the economic policies
and programs followed by the Gorkhali rulers to mobilize human and material
resources for territorial expansion."
Reprinted almost 30 years after its
first appearance, it would have been nice to see a new preface by Regmi,
incorporating his comments on how his early emphasis on the "economic"
seems too one-sided to him now (as can be gathered from his comments in his
1995 book Kings and Political Leaders of the Gorkhali Empire), and why his
hope that this text will channel "Nepali historiography along new
directions" has not been fulfilled.
Lumbini Chakra: Geometric Interpretation of the Archaelogical Remains
(1998, Sashi Rimal) by Shankar Nath Rimal was written in response to a
request by the Lumbini Development Trust regarding how the Mayadevi temple
complex could be reconstructed and developed. Through various
diagram-generating exercises, Rimal tries to prove that Lumbini did not
grow on its own without formal planning, and shows how the remains that
have been located at the birth-site of Gautam Buddha are related to each
other in a geometric pattern. He suspects that "the planning process could
have been initiated by the Emperor Ashoka." We should expect expert
commentary on Rimal's attempt from archaelogists who have studied the site.
Bemousam ka Ragaharu by Lekhnath Bhandari is a mini book. The author calls
it an ensemble of fifty-one word meanings, which are in fact satires; most
of them are cheap, political, and trite. About a five-minute read, the book
is nonetheless worth five rupees, its price.
Jivanka lagi Youn (1998, Udgam Publications, Rs.120) by Shreeramsingh
Basnet explains the importance of sex in human life. It deals with themes
such as menstruation, masturbation, homosexuality, menopause, pregnancy,
etc. with frankness. It reads well and will be useful to readers of all
age. Since the talk of 'sex education' is looming large of late, the book
can be a good reference source.
The Kathmandu Post Review of Books,
Vol 3, no. 18
10 Jan 1999
Coordinated by Dinesh Prasain
Meals for the Mind
C. K. Lal
=09Books are said to nourish the mind. While good books are as rare to
come across as fine cuisine, one still has to find sustenance in books
that may not change the world but are potent enough to keep a person
going. Francis Bacon has observed, "Some books are to be tasted, others
to be swallowed, and some to be chewed and digested." However, one must
first take a bite before deciding what to do with the fare.
=09I love to read all kinds of memoirs. I believe most readers do so,
because it gives them an opportunity to live one added life, that too in
the company of people who have made their mark and left an imprint on
the society. But a biography is a different kettle of fish. Perhaps the
expression should be modified and I should rather say a different pot of
khhichadi altogether. The specific example that I have taken this time
is the biography of Aditya Vikram Birla, and he was a vegetarian.
=09By the time Aditya was born, Birlas were already a name in India. At
eighteen, when he was due to leave for Massachusetts Institute of
Technology with two of his cronies, his grand-father Ghanshyamdas, the
legendary industrialist-friend of Mahatma Gandhi, sent him a =91not-to-do=
=92
list. Among other instructions, it advised him not to dive, not to swim
in the sea and never to study late in the night.
=09Biographer Minhaz Merchant thinks that the readers who have forked out
three hundred and ninety-five Indian Rupees for the hard bound edition
would be interested even in such minutia as, "The boys then caught a
connecting Air-India flight to New York. They checked in at Hotel
Lexington before flying, two days later, to Boston." When an author gets
largest ever fee for a book from the sponsors of an =91authorized
biography=92, what else can one expect except an out and out hagiography?
While this book may be important for those who subscribe to the view of
Carlyle that biography is the only true history, the truth as depicted
in this volume is hardly stranger than fiction. This book makes a bland
reading, like consuming a mountain of Bhaat without accompanying side
dishes. [Aditya Bikram Birla, A Biography by Minhaz Merchant, Viking
Penguin India, 1997]
=09Reminiscences of Nancy Cooke De Herrera, the American lady who claims
to have launched Maharishi Mahesh Yogi=92s multi-pronged marketing
blitzkrieg makes more compelling reading. A much-married socialite of
Beverly Hills with friends high in the glamour world, she seeks
salvation in the company of the Beach Boys and the Beatles in the Valley
of Saints, learns to levitate in Switzerland, goes in search of Shirdi
Sai Baba, dines with Greta Garbo and Dr. Gayelord, poses with the royal
family of Bhutan and travels to Lhasa with Tensing Norgay. When one does
all that, there are stories to hear, however vane the narrator may be.
The book has spiritual pretensions too, but it=92s the anecdotes that make
it a fun-read. It=92s a vegetable curry masaala of a book, full of spice
but not too hot. [Beyond Gurus by Nancy Cooke De Herrera, Rupa, New
Delhi, 1994]
=09After the industrialist and the socialite, Akhtar Hameed Khan is a
person that would not fit any single description. He has been a member
of Indian Civil Service, a teacher at the Jamia Milia Islamia in India,
a visiting professor at the Michigan State University, an innovator who
created the famous Rural Development Academy of Comilla (now in
Bangladesh) with Foundation Funds and Harvard advisors and a social
reformer who headed the legendary urban slum development of Karachi
named Orangi Pilot Project. The man had donned so many hats over the
years that by now he must be having a sizable collection of head-gears.
=09Not all, but quite a few of those caps come shinning through in a
collection of essays. Recently, Akhtar Hameed Khan had expressed in a
media interview that he had only one regret, that to have left Patna. At
eighty-two, one does get a bit reflective and start longing for one=92s
roots. All around, his dreams lie shattered. The Biharis who made
Pakistan possible have been rejected by Bangladesh and disowned by
Pakistan. May be, at the back of his mind, Akhtar Hameed Khan carries a
sense of guilt for having deserted the land of his forefathers for the
promise of a rainbow at the end of the horizon. Now he has discovered
Sheikh Saadi, "Have you arranged your earthly homes properly that you
are flying to arrange things in the sky?"
=09This is one book that I would recommend without reservation to any one
even remotely interested in development studies. Forget the prose and
style, it=92s the substance of the book that is enriching. Like Daal at
our daily meal, it=92s liquid, it=92s easy to digest and it=92s all protein=
=2E
For those of you who have read about him in Himal, the full-serving
would be hugely satisfying. [Akhtar Hameed Khan: Orangi Pilot Project,
Reminiscences and Reflections, Oxford-Karachi, 1996]
=09What would be our daily meal without a selection of pickles--the tasty,
tangy, sour and hot achar marinated in mustard oil and lime juice with
loads of salt? Manohar Malgonkar=92s selection of Dropping Names is
exactly such a fare. To read it on its own may prove to be a bit hard on
the palate, but if you are reading it in bits and pieces along with more
serious stuff, both become more enjoyable.
=09Before acquiring the status of a famous author, Malgonkar spent some
time with the Indian Army. His prose is crisp, no non-sense and
point-blank. There is more in this slim volume of less than two hundred
pages than many other thicker tomes. From Paul Scot to V. S. Naipaul,
from Vijay Raje to Sonia Gandhi, from Khuswant Singh to P. D. Malgavkar
(Never heard of him? Check the India Office Library in London.), one
gets to sample the idiosyncrasies of a galaxy of celebrities, some
richer than famous, some more famous than the rich but all of them
either rich or famous or both. By the way, I read this pack of pickled
chilly-and-tomato in one sitting, going to the extent of reading by the
candle light when load-shedding attempted to interfere with my
indulgence. I intend to read it once again! [Dropping Names by Manohar
Malgonkar, Lotus Roli Books, Delhi, 1996]
=09That was quite a feast I had during Dashai-Tihar vacations. I would
have given an uncivilized belch, but then I bought Alvin and Heidi
Toffler's War and Anti-War, Paul Kennedy=92s Preparing for the
Twenty-First Century and Helga Drummond's Power. Appetite of the mind is
strange--the more you partake, hungrier you get!
The Kathmandu Post Review of Books,
Vol 3, no. 18
10 Jan 1999
Coordinated by Dinesh Prasain
BOOK: Postcolonial Developments: Agriculture in the Making of Modern India
by Akhil Gupta
Durham, Duke University Press
1998, USD 21.95
Reviewed by Tatsuro Fijikura
In the farming village that Akhil Gupta describes in his
Postcolonial Developments, the farmers use apparently non-Western notions,
such as 'heat', 'wetness', and 'wind', to describe their agricultural
practices. At the same time, the same farmers are avid users of such
modern inputs as chemical fertilizers. In other words, the farmers whom
Gupta describes are not unlike many farmers in contemporary Nepal.
Part of what Gupta tries to do, and succeeds through his ethnographic
description of a village in Uttar Pradesh, is to show that most farmers in
South Asia and other 'developing countries' cannot simply be categorized
either as 'modern' or 'non-modern'. The mainstream development ideologues
and the romantic environmentalists, in their different ways, tend to view
such farmers as lagging behind in the ladder of 'modernization', or as
representing an alternative ('indigenous') way of life outside modernity.
Arguing against those views, Gupta maintains that what are often
called 'traditional' or 'indigenous knowledge' ought to be
reconceptualized as representing "culturally constituted recipes for
dealing with the varying conditions and exigencies encountered in farming
activities" in the present - in the particular condition of modernity that
those farmers are engaged in. The ethnographic part of the book, which
includes lengthy excerpts from interviews with farmers on various aspects
of their agricultural practices, shows the villagers' actions as at once
more complex and more sensible than the overarching pictures that some
modernist or anti-modernist writers tend to present.
Gupta's aim, however, is not only to provide ethnographic
descriptions, but to make a further and far-reaching theoretical point.
Gupta argues that the "distinctiveness" of the situation he describes is
that it lacks any "higher-order unity" that is able to coherently explain
all the seemingly contradictory statements and actions observed in the
field.
I personally think it is not necessary to debate here the merits
of his version of 'post-colonial theory'. (The book, by the way, includes
useful summaries of the literature on post-colonial, ecological and
cultural theories.) Rather, I would point out that Gupta's post-modernist
claim of fundamental incoherence seem to be contradicted by his own
analyses of political economy at the village, national, and global levels.
For those analyses, Gupta utilizes such notions as 'class' and 'structural
positions' that seem, indeed to explain much of the phenomena that he
describes.
Indeed, I would argue that one of the very strength of this book
is the authors very clear and informative (albeit sometimes disjointed)
discussions on the dynamics of political economy from local, national to
global levels. Gupta covers such wide ranging topics as technological,
socio- economic and environmental changes brought about by the 'Green
Revolution', populist policies of the Indian government under Indira
Gandhi, various peasant movements, global political economy of food-grains
after the Second World War, discourses and politics of environmentalism,
'sustainable development' and the Rio Earth Summit, and protests and
resistance in India against multinational seed companies and Kentucky
Fried Chicken.
In his discussion of the village political economy, Gupta also
provides analytic- descriptions that tend to corroborate earlier insights
on the transformations in rural South Asia. One example is the notion,
advanced by Adrian Mayor among others, of the shift in the nature of local
leadership in the post-Independence India from patronage to brokerage.
Outcome of this shift is that "Village leaders no longer
cultivated clients chiefly through the use of their own property - by
leasing it to tenants, by employing an unchanging group of laborers and so
forth (that is, by acting as a patron) but rather by facilitating the
delivery of state programs and services (that is, by acting as a broker)."
Another, related example involves the utility of the twin concepts of
entitlement and enfranchisement proposed by Arjun Appadurai.
Appadurai argued that changing dynamics in rural South Asia
involved "a change which gives poorer persons a wider voice in the conduct
of public life [i.e., enfranchisement], but fewer claims upon subsistence
in local economic system [i.e., entitlement]." Gupta finds this process
accompanying the decline of patronage and increasing proletarianization in
the village he describes.
Possible shortcomings of the book include that it is too long
(over 400 pages) and literally too heavy to carry around. More serious
perhaps is the total lack of village women's or children's perspectives in
the book. The descriptions of the village politics and agriculture derive
almost totally from the author's interviews with male household heads.
This lack severely limits the level of ethnographic complexity that the
book is able to attain.
However, the book contains enough insights and information about
the conditions of agrarian life in northern India, seen from the village,
national, and global contexts that makes this book extremely useful for
those of us who want to understand better the conditions of rural life in
Nepal or elsewhere, especially by providing us with regional, comparative
and global perspectives.
(Fujikura is an anthropologist doing research in Nepal)
**********************************************************
To: NEPAL@cs.niu.edu, tiwari@fas.harvard.edu
From: <ipringle@mos.com.np> (ian pringle) (by way of sinhas@mos.com.np (Pratyoush
Onta))
Subject: Recent News
(Jan. '99) A Page of News about Radio Sagarmatha and Community Radio in Nepal
SAFA RADIO: Measuring and publicising air pollution
The new year promises a lot of excitement for community radio in Nepal. To
start it off right, Radio Sagarmatha (RS) launched a new initiative on
January 3, 1999: 'Safa Radio - The Clean Air Campaign'. Air pollution in
the Kathmandu Valley is becoming worse and worse day by day. People are
routinely shocked by the sooty toxic smoke that spews from the exhaust
pipes of a mind-boggling array of vehicles floating around the streets of
the capital. While the particular geography of the Kathmandu Valley is
partly to blame, the total lack of vehicle emission-control is the real
culprit.
Safa Radio - The Clean Air Campaign has been in the works for a while, but
the key elements only came together recently. Led by RS (Radio Sagarmatha),
the project is a partnership with NESS, the Nepal Environmental Scientific
Society, and DANIDA, the development arm of the Danish Government.
Five of seven days of the week, RS's DANIDA-financed 'safa' (Nepali for
clean) tempo - a van-sized three-wheeled electric vehicle that carries a
half dozen or more people - measures the level of air pollutants from a
different location in the city. The results are tested and analysed in a
laboratory, then explained and broadcast the same day during the station's
evening community news bulletin, Haalchaal. In all, there are thirty
locations in which monitoring is carried out on a rotating basis. Following
five days of readings and broadcasts, the cumulative results are discussed
on-the-air in a special weekly forum; monthly, the results are presented to
the media and the public in a press conference.
Safa Radio is an example of how a community radio can not only present news
and issues for discussion, but also take a leading and visible role in
tackling problems, not just program from the studio, but take to the
streets and work in the community.
Mobile Radio: On the Road
Taking the radio out of the station into the communities that the majority
of Nepalis live in has been a long time goal of many at Radio Sagarmatha.
The station's establishment has always been envisioned as a beginning, a
starting point for a wider role in community-based radio in Nepal. Although
several communities outside the Kathmandu Valley have already initiated the
process of starting local stations of their own, most people have never
been exposed to radio other than national and international services...
certainly not a type of radio they do for themselves.
In November 1998, to the surprise of many given the five year struggle to
get a license for Radio Sagarmatha itself, the station received permission
to run a mobile radio service anywhere in Nepal using the station's
Kathmandu frequency, 102.4 FM. The idea isn't to extend RS's Kathmandu
service, but rather to bring the idea of local radio to some of Nepal's 90%
who live in rural areas and small communities. Beginning the next few
months, Radio Sagarmatha, in partnership with MS Nepal (Denmark) will
outfit a vehicle with a small studio and transmitter and hit the road. By
keeping it simple, doing basic training and getting local people involved,
Sagarmatha Mobile Radio will work to demystify radio and get communities
interested in starting their own local radios.
Cultural Programmes: Bridging Gaps
Nepal has a long and powerful tradition of oral folk media. As recently as
fifty years ago, the main source of news for many communities were roaming
artists who spread the word about happenings through specially composed
songs. Other varieties served more educational and entertainment roles,
some relating history, others religious epics, some using poetry, other
using question and answer styles of interaction. These folk media were in
many respects the pre-cursors of today's radio and television services and
provide a culturally appropriate model for newer media. RS has introduced a
daily radio serial which explores these cultural traditions, some featuring
rare selections and recordings, some using adaptations to bring them into
today's context and still others employing traditional methods with modern
materials.
Building Training and Resources for Nepal and South Asia
RS has gone through a lot of changes in the past four months and is poised
for growth in the near future. In October of 1998, the station made the
jump from a two-hour to a six-hour daily programme service. A month later,
permission came for a twenty-four hour service and approval was given to
run a mobile service. Communities in other parts of Nepal are thinking
about their own local stations. Two licenses have already been granted. As
RS continues to expand its own services and more and more communities, both
in Nepal and other parts of South Asia, get closer to broadcast, the demand
for general support as well as training in radio broadcasting skills and
organisational management will increase. It is essential that steps be
taken now to prepare for the challenges.
With this need and urgency in mind, Radio Sagarmatha is working to lay the
foundations for an effective training and resource infrastructure which can
support the development of other independent community-oriented media. As
with all of its current plans the station is looking for international
partners to help get the ball rolling. As more and more public-interest and
community-based radio initiatives turn to Radio Sagarmatha for advice,
assistance and training, the impact of such a resource promises to be
significant and extensive. Naturally, the real beneficiaries are radio
listeners and as a result of increased public dialogue and participation,
South Asian communities and societies overall.
'Things You Wanted to Know About Radio Sagarmatha' is an organisational
profile of Nepal's first community-based, public-interest radio station. It
covers things from mandate to the Nepal broadcast environment to current
programmes to technical specifications. If you're interested in seeing a
copy, send us a note and we'll email you. (It is available in MS Word, with
for Windows or Mac... or by post).
And just in case you didn't already know: Between January 18-21, Tambuli
Radio is hosting the third national gathering of community radios in the
Philippines.
ian.
Note: Radio Sagarmatha envisions this update about community radio
activities in Nepal as an occasional service for at least as long as we've
got interesting things to say. For one reason or another, we though you
might be interested. Please feel free to share news and if you'd rather not
receive it, please accept our apologies and send us an email letting us
know.
radio sagarmatha: gpo box 6958 - kathmandu, nepal; wk: (977-1) 528 091
fax: 530 227; hm: 422 139 mail: c/o ceci; gpo box 2959 - kathmandu,
nepal; email: <ipringle@mos.com.np> <ipringle@vcn.bc.ca>
radio sagarmatha (lic. 1997) is south asia's first independent
community-based broadcaster representing a himalayan opportunity for public
interest communications and development in the subcontinent. the initiative
is sponsored in part by ceci, the canadian centre for international studies
and cooperation. if you would like a one page summary of the station's
mandate and activities or other information about radio sagarmatha return
email.
ceci, the centre for international studies and cooperation is a canadian
ngo with a country office in nepal. through the volunteer cooperation
program, ceci brings canadian professions to work with local groups like
radio sagarmatha.
-------------------------
Book Review: contd....
State Dept. Magazine's "Post of the Month" for july 98. Found on the internet:
Kathmandu:
A Mecca in a Land of Legends
By Micaela Schweitzer
While the metamorphosis of the hair and lice may be questionable, that the
Kathmandu Valley was once a lake and that the valley has a
beauty capable of captivating a god are certainly fact. Though pollution
clouds the air of the valley now, when the skies are clear and the
Himalayas tower over the northern hills, one can imagine the splendor that
evoked such devotion from Manjushri. Over the years,
Kathmandu's beauty and magic have entranced many visitors. Many have been
so captivated they're unable to leave. Approximately
3,000 American expatriates, for example, live full time in Kathmandu, and
others return year after year. In all, more than 25,000
Americans tour Nepal annually.
Closed to all outsiders until 1951, Nepal has heartily embraced its role as
a tourist hot spot and manages to offer something for
everyone. For outdoorsmen, trekking in the Himalayas provides spectacular
views, breathtaking climbs and charming encounters with
yaks and Sherpas, while trips down the sacred rivers from Tibet offer
exciting white- water rafting and glimpses of unspoiled terrain.
Those interested in less strenuous entertainment visit Nepal's grassland
nature preserves in search of rhinos, tigers and bears or shop
for precious gems, handwoven carpets and unique Nepalese crafts.
Nepal is certainly a place of contrasts. Its geography ranges from hot,
steamy plains to glacial mountains. Although its people are
friendly and welcoming, their culture and religion remain a mystery to
most. Closed to the outside world for centuries, Nepal has since
embraced the residence of many foreigners, including large populations of
Tibetan and Bhutanese refugees. While Nepal has attracted
investment from some of the biggest American firms, it remains one of the
world's poorest countries.
Nepal's variety is reflected in the U.S. mission's work. The consular
section, for example, has gained world-wide attention for
assisting American mountain climbers, most recently in May 1996's dramatic
helicopter rescue on Mount Everest. Other mission
efforts, though less dramatic, include supporting Nepal's young democracy
(the country was an absolute monarchy until 1990);
promoting U.S. business, especially in developing Nepal's hydropower; and
assisting more than 110,000 refugees.
Global issues, too, have taken on particular importance in this region.
Kathmandu is the Department's regional environmental hub for
South Asia. U.S. officials are conducting research to find a vaccine for
hepatitis E. Nepal's famous soldiers, the "Gurkhas," find their
modern-day counterparts in the Royal Nepalese Army, which staunchly
supports U.N. peacekeeping. The U.S. Agency for
International Development has a $26 million annual program focused on
agriculture, health and women's empowerment. The oldest and
largest Peace Corps program in Asia is in Nepal, with about 150 volunteers
doing everything from providing basic health education to
creating wildlife data bases. (At least two Nepal Peace Corps alumni, Peter
Burleigh and Peter Tomsen, became U.S. ambassadors.)
The U.S. Information Service maintains active programs for a very receptive
audience (see USIS sidebar).
Both at work and at play, Kathmandu, a mysterious city hidden among the
world's highest mountains, offers a fascinating experience
that makes it a popular post and that causes many mission members to seek
repeat tours.
The author is a junior political/consular officer in Kathmandu.
*****************************************************************
Date: Tue, 19 Jan 1999 02:51:22 -0500
From: "Paramendra Bhagat"<paramendra_bhagat@smtpgtwy.berea.edu>
To: <nepal@cs.niu.edu>
Subject: A Total Spread of Democracy and Free Markets
To: Dean Schmidt
Cc: Dr. Boyd, Dr. Burnside, Dr. Crowden
Bcc: Dr. Heyrman, Dr. Rifai, Dr. Berheide
Dear Dean Schmidt,
I am a Junior, Political Science Major. I request a change of Major to Sociology
and two additional semesters of stay that this change will entail. I would
greatly appreciate the help on your part.
After a long period of cerebral creative confusion I have come to the conclusion
it is best for me to make Sociology the focus of the rest of my undergraduate
studies. This shift on my part is akin to the urge to dip into chemistry before
going onto Medical School, to delve into high-falutin' mathematics before going
on to do complex work in Economics at Graduate School: it is about going to the
basics so as to refuse to take even the fundamental and the obvious of group
dynamics and the political process for obvious.
I have come to believe life is best lived one step at a time. Life is more
fulfilling when you commit yourself to a process rather than some distant
destination so as to better appreciate the flux of the circumstances along any
possible career path. This is my chance to explore my abilities and aptitudes,
strengthen them as well my weaknesses as seen in light of those strengths. There
are so many uncertainties, so many changes one can not hope to foresee until the
very final moments when change faces us a galore, and this might be my time to
explore myself more fully, expand the contours of my mind, now when I am not yet
in the straitjacket of a particular career path. It is said of most people in my
generation that we will have had seven different careers before we retire in
earnest.
Why do some dedicate their lives to obscure theoretical explorations that whisk
them off onto lonely tangents whereas others jump into the the thick of the
largest of crowds where the possibilities of being whisked off onto lonely
tangents are equally large? A modest explanation would be aptitude. People serve
themselves and the world they are a part of best when they get to cash on their
aptitudes. Although I would hope my curiosities will burn all my life for all
domains the human mind roams in, I can comfortably say I find myself in the
domain of the social sciences. I consider myself a student of group dynamics, of
the political process.
Cells are made up of atoms, but no matter how much you learn about atoms, you
will still have to study cells as cells to learn about them: you can not study
atoms and be able to understand cells. There is a perspective Sociology throws
that is unique and in some ways central to the various themes of the social
sciences in general. Why do social institutions act the way they act? Why do
people act the way they act in different social settings? How does one's socio-
cultural upbringing end up having such a central grip on one's sense of identity
and end up affecting one's thought processes and behavior in ways most often not
acknowledged even to oneself?
After one talk on Relativity Albert Einstein went onto say,"And the rest is
merely details!" I am afraid a lot of the thinkers and the power brokers in the
established democracies tend to take a similar attitude about democracy, not a
super form of government but the best that we have, as Churchill said, or free
markets, the best method to create wealth humankind ever came up with, as
Gorbachev put it.
As a student of political economy, I look around and see the Total Spread of
Democracy and Free Markets as the next Giant Leap. No one can really tell if the
Leap will be gradual or sudden as in the case of the demise of the Soviet Union.
Coming from the second poorest country on the planet that has had British-style
parliamentary democracy with a constitutional monarchy for over eight years now,
a country where the largest political party is socialist, the second and the
third largest presences in the parliament are communist (and there are about
nine other smaller communist parties; armed Maoist guerrillas affect almost
half the country in some ways), a country where it is taken for granted that
elections will be rigged, campaign contributions are totally opaque, a huge
chunk of the state budget simply disappears in a routine fashion - these to show
that democracy has not yet taken firm roots in the country - and there is not a
single major political party that claims to be a proponent of the free market
ways; having been involved in active politics for a couple of years in a modest
capacity - I was with a tiny political party that had two Members of Parliament
in its ranks - what I see is it is not hard to see the ultimate goodness of
democracy and free markets. When you bring those two together in fairness,
social justice is a foregone conclusion as is genuine creation of wealth as
opposed to the professed distribution of wealth you do not have; what is
gripping is to try and understand the conditions that prevent those huge
populations in the Global South from embracing these two fundamental concepts,
hence my curiosities about the more raw social sciences.
I for one believe Democracy and Free Markets are as western a concept as the
Theory of Relativity is Jewish or the Universal Law of Gravitation is English.
Beyond a point the fruits of labor of the thinkers and the academics is the
common property of all humankind to dip into and make the best use of for the
largest possible common good.
It seems it is not enough to say popularly elected governments are better. It is
not enough to say markets are the best mechanism created to date by humankind
for the creation of wealth. I think the greater challenge lies in first
understanding why those populations not yet under democratic regimes act the way
they act and put up with what they put up with. If they are the less
enlightened, as they are constantly told, it is the greater responsibility of
the "enlightened" to first understand their conditions prescriptions are
offered.
I think this is my time to spread broad and crown my undergraduate years with
the queen of the social sciences - Sociology - with room to explore the rest of
the social sciences, and the other areas of studies so that I can better
concentrate on possibly acquiring a degree in International Law, law being the
what societies gel into, the law being the true reflection of group dynamics in
concrete action, the ultimate application, and at times the thick of the fight
for simple and momentous social changes.
I earnestly hope I will get the requisite help from you.
Thank you for your support and your caring interest in my progress here at Berea
College.
Yours sincerely,
Paramendra Bhagat
Mainstreaming the Nepal Sadbhavana Party
by Paramendra Bhagat
<http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/9511>
Nepal Human Development Report 1998
<http://www.nepali.net/undp/keydoc/nhdr98/contents.html>
The World Bank Group: Country Data on Nepal
<http://www.worldbank.org/data/countrydata/countrydata.html>
The World Bank in Nepal: Development Indicators
<http://www.worldbank.org.np/worldbank/indicator.html>
Structural Adjustment in Nepal
<http://www.worldbank.org/html/oed/pr122.htm>
Nepal: Environment and Development
<http://www.info-nepal.com/nhp/econ/env/unced.html>
Nepalnet: Economy
<http://www.PanAsia.org.sg/nepalnet/ecnoframe.htm>
People’s Review: Economic gloom and doom
<http://www.info-nepal.com/p-review/1999/01/070199/pol.html>
Emergence as a constitutionally-recognized national party----------
It was no small feat for the Nepal Sadbhavana Party to gain its national
status in the aftermath of the first parliamentary elections held after
the reinstatement of democracy in 1990. It garnered the required minimum
of five per cent of the votes cast, alright, but barely that. For the
first time, the dignity of the Terai had been placed as a distinct issue
on the national political landscape. In the aftermath every political
party of some import has had to deal with the issue. That has been the
Sadbhavana's first major accomplishment.
Poor performance in the second elections contested in Gajendra Narayan
Singh's leadership--------------------------------------------------
Although the Sadbhavana retained its national party status in the
aftermath of the mid-term polls Girija Koirala rushed the country into,
its size in the parliament was a reduced one and so was its share of
votes. In the aftermath Gajendra Narayan Singh, as reported by those in
his close circles, was blaming the Teraiwasis rather than the
deficiencies in his leadership style for the sorry debacle. In the
business world, they say, the consumers are always right. In electoral
politics the voters are the consumers. What Singh failed to ask himself
was as to why the Teraiwasi voters were not turning to the Sadbhavana en
masse even when its espoused cause is just and in the Terai's best
interests.
There were expectations then that Sarlahi District, the strongest
Sadbhavana district in the Eastern Terai, might send some Sadbhavana
stalwarts into the parliament; that wish did not materialize. There were
some close losses owing primarily to the Congress misuse of money and
muscle.
Saptari did good in that both Gajendra Narayan Singh and Anis Ansari
won, although some ascribe that to a disproportionately large
expenditure of the Sadbhavana funds in Singh's constituency. The
Sadbhavana candidate Dilip Dhadewa, a Biratnagar Marwadi, gave tough
competition to Shailaja Acharya in her Morang constituency. That too was
remarkable. The candidate still holds promise. And, of course, Harka Lal
Rajbanshi put up a strong showing in Jhapa.
But there was a downslide in the western Terai. Mirza Dil Sad Beg went
over to the RPP ranks. Some say Gajendra Narayan Singh was pressured to
send him out. Others say that Mirza did indeed have underworld links and
felt it safer to gang up with the crooks in the RPP and so willingly
defected. Whatever the underlying fact, the western Terai that had sent
five Sadbhavana leaders as MPs the first time around sent only one
during the second hustings in the person of Hridayesh Tripathy of the
Public-Accounts-Committee-fame. The-then Vice-President of the
Sadbhavana, some Triyogi Narayan Chaudhary, who had been a Sadbhavana MP
the first time around, ran against Tripathy on a Congress ticket.
Tripathy won anyway, but Sadbhavana lost four MPs in the process. The
story goes that Girija Koirala first tried to buy off Tripathy. On
failing that he bought off Chaudhary - some put the figure at eight
lakhs - and sent him running against Tripathy.
But thanks to the hung parliament, the Sadbhavana has managed to get
into power several times in the second, hung parliament, even when it
had split, and had two MPs in one party and two in another - in the
Nepal Samajwadi Janata Dal - for all practical purposes. Although its
agenda was not advanced - though promises were made by the dominant
coalition partner each time it came into power - the Sadbhavana did get
its first tastes of power. All its four MPs, Rameshwar Raya Yadav of the
Upper House included, made it into the Cabinet at one time or the other.
Mirza too made it, though as a RPP candidate. Thanks also to the hung
parliament, Tripathy got himself elected Chairperson of the
all-important Public Accounts Committee (Atal Bihari Vajpayee held the
same Chair in the Indian parliament before he went on to become Prime
Minister of India). Again, Mirza also got himself elected Chair of
another parliamentary committee.
And then we have the newest coalition that is to hold the next
elections, and Gajendra Narayan Singh is in again.
In hindsight it might seem the hung parliament brought myriad windfalls
to the Sadbhavana, but the party has failed to cash on that so as to
grow and mature ideologically, expand organizationally, both within and
beyond the Terai, and hold promise as a party that might send not six
not three but 10, 20, 30, or more MPs onto the national stage.
Gajendra Narayan Singh's greatest blunder: Not accepting Tripathy's
election as Chair of the Public Accounts Committee----------------
Gajendra Narayan Singh must be credited with having made sacrifices
spanning a lifetime that the Sadbhavana has cashed on - there is no
doubt about that - though he is not the only one as those in the
Sadbhavana who have been trying to build political careers out of an
unquestioning hero-worship of Singh would like you to belive: there are
myriad giants of various political persuasions from the past on whose
shoulders he stands. And the first general elections the Sadbhavana
contested benefitted greatly from his leadership, no doubt, but just
when the Sadbhavana had a chance to grow organizationally and expand
ideologically after the second, hung parliament gelled and Tripathy got
himself elected Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, Gajendra Narayan
Singh blew it. Singh ought to take sole responsibility for the massive
waste of energy as evidenced in the split of the Sadbhavana party.
Tripathy, a MP of a party that had only three seats in the Lower House,
managed to get himself elected Chair of the largest and most prestigious
parliamentary committee that had 33 MPs on its rolls, and instead of
seeing it as a huge victory for the party Singh felt dwarfed instead.
Here was a chance for the Sadbhavana to become a two-issue party - the
dignity of the Terai and the fight against corruption - as opposed to
the single-issue party it had been all along. The Terai-specific issue
was its identity, but it also hindered it from growing organizationally.
Here was a chance for the Sadbhavana to grow and Singh blew it. The
energy that would have gone into expanding the party's organizational
presence went into an overblown intra-party warfare.
The break-away Nepal Samajwadi Janata Dal joked that all those who had
been garnering at least 10,000 votes - Harka Lal Singh Rajbanshi, Dilip
Dhadewa, Rameshwar Raya Yadav, Rajendra Mahato, the star-figure Tripathy
himself, and several others - had come with the Dal, the rest who made
political careers hovering around the party office 10-5 were left with
the Sadbhavana.
And the Dal took another giant leap besides accepting corruption as a
major issue in projecting Rameshwar Raya Yadav as its President. If at
the national level, there was the Teraiwasi-Pahadwasi issue, at the
Terai level there was the politics of the backward and the foreward
castes, Bihar-style, and the Dal responded to that ground reality
sensitively. The Sadbhavana, even after coming back together, has not
managed to do the same.
The re-united Sadbhavana will have to project Rameshwar Raya Yadav more
forcefully than it has so far. Maybe the Sadbhavana, at its next
national convention, ought to imitate the Nepal Samajwadi Janata Dal,
and put forth Yadav as the first in command and Tripathy as its second
in command figure. That would be more appealing to the voters of the
Terai than the current makeup where most of the Sadbhavana leaders are
high-caste personalities. If not the Sadbhavana will fail to project an
image of a party that stands for social justice. High-caste domination
is the status quo in the Terai as in the country at large.
The Vertical Splits in the UML and the RPP: To the Sadbhavana's
Advantage ----------------------------------------------------------
One would think this would be the Sadbhavana's chance. The-then largest
party in the parliament, the UML, underwent a vertical split, and so did
the third largest party, the RPP. The Congress might have become the
status quo but so was the Panchayat regime once. The Congress has lost
steam as exposed in the lack of spine on the part of its
second-generation leaders to outdo the Koirala-Bhattarai duo and speed
up the modernization of the party.
On the contrary a split Sadbhavana, that in its splitting might have set
off the chain reaction that caught the UML and the RPP, finally came
together. The Nepal Samajawadi Janata Dal was dissolved and Hridayesh
Tripathy, Rameshwar Raya Yadav, Rajendra Mahato, Dilip Dhadewa and Harka
Lal Singh Rajbanshi came back into the Sadbhavana mainstream. The
Sadbhavana might still get more than 10 seats in the parliament, but the
question is can it hope to emerge as a party to have crossed the 50-seat
mark over the next few national election cycles? That is the question
the Sadbhavana faces right now.
So far the Sadbhavana seems not to have managed a massive organizational
expansion the vertical splits in the second and the third largest
parties allowed it. It continues to parrot its four or five points as if
to say the Sadbhavana leaders have been right along, if only the voters
would get the message! The party ought to change its defeatist mentality
and adopt a the-voters-are-always-right attitude.
Three Mantras: The Economy, The Economy, The Economy----------------
The most important question that the Sadbhavana faces is does it wish to
continue to be a political party that has an organizational base only in
the 16 districts of the Terai as opposed to the 75 districts in the
nation at large even if the 16 Terai districts cover half the national
population? Does it hope to continue to be a party that will get
anywhere between 5-20 seats election after election or does it hope to
go on to become a party that will cross the magic figure of 103 some day
over the next 3-4 electoral cycles? Does it wish to continue having a
Central Committee peopled exclusively by the Dhoti-Kurta people or does
it wish to bring some Topi-Kurta-Suruwals into its folds at the central
level?
If it is the latter and the Sadbhavana does wish to enter the national
mainstream rather than continue staying on the fringes it might be time
the Yadav-Tripathy duo moved towards providing leadership to the party
and gave the party ideology a major restructuring and focused on the
National Economy "with the intensity of a laser beam" without abandoning
the four or five issues the Sadbhavana has been touting since its
inception. Microsoft underwent a major restructuring of its vision in
1995 when it finally made internet the focus of all it does. For the
Sadbhavana the focus ought to be the National Economy. It is only with
such a change in focus will it be able to make progress also on its
current pet issues.
None of the pet issues of the Sadbhavana will materialize unless the
Nepalese in the hill districts agree to them. But then if the Nepalese
in the hills and mountains are to understand the urge for the issues
espoused by the Sadbhavana leaders over the past eight years, would it
not be understandable that they would expect the Sadbhavana leaders, at
the same time, would acknowledge there can be no larger issue than the
National Economy for the peoples of the second poorest country on the
planet? In fact the Sadbhavana ought to make the National Economy its
number one issue even if it were to continue to be a Terai-based outfit.
The National Economy is the number one concern also for the voters in
the Terai, more than half of whom are dirt poor anyway.
Otherwise the Sadbhavana has, in its past eight years of its existence,
managed to be the voice only of a tiny segment of the middle and upper
middle class high caste voters in the Terai. Either it changes or it
keeps to its single-digit-figure presence in the national legislature
for the foreseeable future.
Economy of Nepal
<http://www.emulateme.com/economy/nepaeco.htm>
Theodora.com: Nepal’s Economy 1995
<http://www.theodora.com/wfb/nepal_economy.html>
Library of Congress: Nepal, Economy
<http://lcweb2.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/r?frd/cstdy:@field(DOCID+np0009)>
CIA World Fact Book: Nepal
<http://www.odci.gov/cia/publications/factbook/np.html>
Nepalpages.com: Doing business in Nepal
<http://www.nepalpages.com/pages/business.htm>
Center for Global Trade Development
<http://www.cgtd.com/global/asia/nepal.htm>
Webnepal.com: Economy
<http://www.webnepal.com/nepal/economy/economy.htm>
Ministry of Commerce: Export Promotion Board
<http://www.info-nepal.com/epb/>
Nepal Information Center: Business and Economy
<http://infosys.zdv.uni-mainz.de/~baadj000/economy.htm>
******************************************************************************
* *
* The Nepal Digest(TND) is a publication of TND Foundation, a global *
* not-for-profit information and resource center committed to promoting *
* issues concerning Nepal. All members of tnd@nepal.org will get a copy of *
* The Nepal Digest (TND). Membership is free of charge and open to all. *
* *
* TND Foundation Home Page: http://www.nepal.org *
* http://www.himalaya.org *
* http://www.gurkhas.org *
* For Information: tnd@nepal.org *
* webmaster: tnd@nepal.org *
* *
* TND Foundation contributions (TAX-DEDUCTIBLE) can be mailed payable to: *
* TND Foundation *
* P.O. Box 8206 *
* White Plains, NY 10601 *
* USA *
* *
* Subscription/Deletion requests : mailto:TND@NEPAL.ORG *
* Provide one line message: sub nepal "lastname, firstname, mi" <user@host> *
* [OPTIONAL] Provide few lines about your occupation, address, phone for *
* TND database to: <TND@NEPAL.ORG> *
* *
* Postal-Mail Correspondences to: TND Foundation *
* P.O. Box 8206 *
* White Plains, NY 10602 *
* USA *
* *
* Digest Contributions: mailto:NEPAL@MP.CS.NIU.EDU *
* THE EDITOR RESERVES THE RIGHT TO EDIT ARTICLES FOR CLARITY. *
* Contributors need to supply Header for the article, email, and full name. *
* *
* Postings are divided into following categories that are listed in the *
* order below. Please provide category-type in the header of your e-mail. *
* *
* 1. Message from TND Editorial Staff *
* TND Foundation News/Message *
* 2. Letter to the Editor *
* Letter to TND Foundation *
* 3. TAJA_KHABAR: Current News *
* 4. KATHA_KABITA: Literature *
* 5. KURA_KANI: Economics *
* Agriculture/Forestry *
* Health *
* Education *
* Technology *
* Social/Cultural Issues *
* Environment/Population *
* Women/Children *
* Tourism *
* Foreign Policy *
* History *
* Military/Police *
* Politics *
* 6. CHOOT_KILA (Humor, Recipies, Movie Reviews, Sattaires etc.) *
* 7. JAN_KARI: Classifides (Matrimonials, Jobs etc) *
* 8. KHOJ_KHABAR (Inquiring about Nepal, Nepalis etc. ) *
* 9. TITAR_BITAR: Miscellaneous (Immigration and Taxex etc. ) *
* *
* COPYRIGHT NOTE *
* -------------- *
* The content contributors are responsible for any copyright violations. *
* TND, a non-profit electronic journal, will publish articles that have *
* been published in other electronic or paper journal with proper credit *
* to the original media. *
* *
******************************************************************************
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%% %
%% END OF "THE NEPAL DIGEST". %
%% %
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue Jan 11 2000 - 11:16:06 CST